COP 28 Slug Fest Over Language Heats Up

Join every day information updates from CleanTechnica on e-mail. Or observe us on Google Information!

COP 28 is scheduled to wrap up in two days time, however this 12 months’s convention is slowed down in semantics because the delegates from numerous nations push their very own agendas. The central failing of this and all COP conferences is that the foundations require any ultimate assertion to be authorised unanimously by all convention members — an association that offers monumental energy to laggards who need to sluggish stroll local weather motion to avoid wasting their very own skins. At COP 26, a final minute demand to insert the phrase “phase-down” into the ultimate communiqué led to president Akok Sharma studying it in tears.

Kuwait Wades In

This 12 months, greater than 100 nations are advocating for a press release that requires a “section out” of fossil fuels whereas the members of OPEC are being urged to withstand such language with each fiber of their being. In a letter dated December 6, Haitham Al-Ghais, secretary normal of the Group of the Petroleum Exporting Nations, warned all members that there was rising stress on the summit to focus on fossil fuels. He known as these plans “politically motivated campaigns” in opposition to oil-rich nations that put “our folks’s prosperity and future in danger.”

The New York Occasions reviews the letter was despatched to the 13 members of OPEC plus 10 extra nations that kind what is called OPEC Plus, which incorporates Russia. “Plainly the undue and disproportionate stress in opposition to fossil fuels could attain a tipping level with irreversible penalties,” Mr. Al-Ghais wrote. He urged the petroleum producers to “reject any textual content or formulation that targets vitality, i.e. fossil fuels, reasonably than emissions.”

COP 28 Draft Assertion

A draft of the textual content of a ultimate assertion made public by COP 28 officers on Friday included a number of choices for ultimate language, starting from a name to phaseout fossil fuels “consistent with the most effective obtainable science,” to no point out at all the way forward for oil, fuel and coal. The probabilities additionally included a phaseout of “unabated” fossil fuels, a obscure time period that means that oil, fuel and coal might proceed for use as lengthy there was expertise to seize and retailer the ensuing carbon emissions. No such expertise at present exists on the scale that scientists say is required, the New York Occasions famous.

2023 will go down as the most popular 12 months in recorded historical past and but the OPEC nations are adopting a head within the sand strategy regardless of warnings from scientists and a rising checklist of local weather disasters affecting each nook of the globe that’s growing stress on the diplomats gathered in Dubai to take motion.

The letter reveals “that fossil gasoline pursuits are beginning to understand that the writing is on the wall for soiled vitality,” mentioned Mohamed Adow, of Energy Shift Africa. “Local weather change is killing poor folks across the globe and these petro-states don’t need COP 28 to section out fossil fuels as a result of it is going to damage their short-term income. It’s shameful.

“The truth is, if the world goes to avoid wasting itself, it can’t be held again by a small band of nations that management the world’s oil provide. In addition to saving us from local weather change, a renewable-powered world can be one the place vitality is dispersed and democratised. Fossil fuels hold energy within the palms of the few that occur to have them.”

On Saturday, a small group of local weather activists from the group 350.org staged a sit-in on the OPEC Pavilion on the summit. “It is a clear obstruction to the local weather talks,” one of many protesters mentioned. “As a result of we want a quick, truthful, perpetually phaseout of fossil fuels now. ”

Cansın Leylim, affiliate director of world campaigns for  350.org mentioned in a press release, “OPEC’s determined resistance to a fossil gasoline phaseout reveals their concern of a altering tide, evident in COP28 discussions. As 106 nations rally for a fast fossil gasoline decline, the draft textual content of the World Stocktake affords hope with a number of choices for a phaseout of fossil fuels. OPEC must get with this system or transfer out of the best way of our simply transition to a 100% renewable vitality powered future. COP28 was speculated to be essentially the most inclusive of local weather talks, but fossil gasoline lobbyists have discovered shelter, and are attempting to dam progress. The highlight is now on the COP28’s Presidency and if they are going to dealer a deal for a simply transition or as an alternative align themselves with the oil trade.”

COP 28 And Sultan Al Jaber

The reply to that query continues to be very a lot up within the air, because the president of the COO 28 summit is on file as saying if we cease burning fossil fuels, we are going to all want to return to residing in caves. He says he was misquoted however the video of his remarks says in any other case.

Sources inform the New York Occasions that through the first week of negotiations, Saudi Arabia moved to dam a number of proposals relating to a phaseout of fossil fuels. They declare Saudi Arabia’s negotiators have merely refused to have interaction in any discussions about the way forward for fossil fuels.

Al Gore is pushing for modifications to the U.N. guidelines in order that future agreements would require approval from a supermajority of 75 % of nations, reasonably than unanimous consent. Below the present guidelines, international locations must “beg for permission from the petro-states” to “shield the way forward for humanity,” Gore mentioned at an occasion hosted by Bloomberg at COP 28.

Senator Ed Markey, a Democrat from Massachusetts, is arriving at COP 28 this weekend with a bipartisan group of Home and Senate members. He advised the New York Occasions he’s apprehensive concerning the heavy focus of fossil gasoline lobbyists on the summit. The Related Press estimates there are at the very least 1,300 fossil gasoline lobbyists are in attendance whereas a coalition of environmental teams examined registration information and put the quantity at greater than 2,400. “These lobbyists are decided to lock us right into a fossil fueled path,” Mr. Markey mentioned.

Marty Durbin, the senior vp for coverage at the USA Chamber of Commerce, maintained that oil executives had been out in power at COP28 as a result of they wished to be “a part of the answer.” He mentioned the references to fossil fuels within the ultimate settlement weren’t as necessary because the pledges many oil firms made this week to curb methane, a greenhouse fuel, and cut back carbon dioxide emissions.

Abatement And Carbon Seize

There may be some fact to that. Fossil gasoline firms are all jiggly over the concept that they will burn coal, oil, and fuel and easily seize the ensuing carbon emissions and bury them underground, within the ocean, or maybe disguise them within the pantry with their cupcakes. Sadly, as anybody with an IQ larger than an armadillo is aware of, all these abatement procedures are an phantasm. Whereas they promise to seize as much as 90 % of emissions, in truth they sequester about 10 % at most. To make issues worse, the price of these paltry efforts is as much as $300 per ton — far too excessive to be of any business worth.

The place Do The Chinese language Match Into The Dialog?

At COP 26, India and China had been the 2 international locations that pressured the change from “phase-out” to “phase-down.” This 12 months, India and China are at odds and China could also be extra amenable to taking a stronger place on fossil fuels. Only a few weeks in the past, Chinese language local weather envoy Xie Zhenhua met with US local weather envoy John Kerry. Afterwards, the pair introduced a brand new settlement to curb methane emissions.

Now The Guardian reviews that China could also be prepared to attempt to discover a option to minimize the Gordian Knot on the coronary heart of this 12 months’s local weather negotiations. It says China wish to see nations comply with substitute renewable vitality for fossil fuels. Xie Zhenhua, China’s local weather envoy, wouldn’t be specific on whether or not China supported or opposed a phase-out of fossil fuels, which greater than 100 governments are pushing for on the COP 28 UN summit. However he did point out that he and his delegation had been partaking positively to attempt to discover a compromise on the contentious concern

Xie did gave a sign of what China sees as a potential compromise, by referring to a joint assertion made with John Kerry, the US local weather envoy, at that assembly in Sunnylands, California, in November. “We had this language which mentioned that each China and the US will massively promote renewable vitality deployment and use it to step by step and orderly substitute for oil, fuel and coal energy era, in order that we are able to cut back greenhouse fuel emissions,” Xie mentioned by way of an interpreter at a small press convention attended by The Guardian on Saturday night.

Typically one of the best ways previous an impediment is to go round it. Maybe China can get others to endorse such an finish run. If it does, there could also be a glimmer of hope for the world to keep away from a full scale meltdown, each figuratively and actually.