Can a Radically Totally different Strategy to EVs Outperform Tesla’s Numbers Benefit?

Join every day information updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or observe us on Google Information!

There are a lot of areas of automotive life the place we like to check the numbers. Which automobile has extra horsepower? Which of them has extra torque? What’s the 0-60 time? Quarter mile? EVs add to this numbers warfare with issues like EPA or WLTP vary, charging speeds, variety of motors, and the robustness of the charging community.

As a lot as I dislike Tesla’s strategy to automotive design (particularly the interiors), and as aggravated as I’m on the conduct of the corporate’s most public face, it could be silly to disclaim that Tesla has the numbers benefit within the EV trade. That is very true in the USA, the place most EVs offered are Teslas and the Supercharger community is each numerically superior and extra dependable than the CCS community. Tesla’s automobiles aren’t one of the best automobiles on the street in any method, however they’re higher EVs than most of what the competitors sells.

It’s going to be extraordinarily troublesome for different producers to catch up. Tesla has round a decade’s head begin over American and European automakers. This time not solely offers them a manufacturing numbers benefit, but in addition the expertise constructing EVs, software program, and charging networks.

As I’ve written in regards to the disappointing development in EV gross sales (one thing that’s negatively affecting Tesla proper now, too), I’m beginning to wonder if catching as much as Tesla is the good transfer in any respect. I’m already aggravated that different automakers are attempting to construct Tesla clones that cost at Tesla chargers and work like a Tesla, as a result of this in the end limits the innovation and competitors that the trade can produce.

However, as a substitute of attempting to outplay Tesla at a recreation they pioneered, perhaps different automakers ought to have a look at this example as a possibility for extra outdoors the field considering. However, getting there’s going to imply questioning and difficult a variety of automotive trade, transportation, and cultural assumptions.

Let’s check out a few of the assumptions in hopes that folks will query them extra and provide you with higher concepts than I can.

Assumption #1: Persevering with The Nineteen Fifties Strategy, However Underneath Electrical Energy

The straightforward reality is that automobiles haven’t basically modified in an extended, very long time. They nearly all have 4 wheels, drive in a standard-width site visitors lane, park in normal parking areas, and drive on the identical sorts of roads. They’ve tremendously improved in security, effectivity, reliability, and luxury over the many years, however they’re nonetheless simply automobiles.

I’ll get some flack from the “Do you actually assume you’re smarter than the richest man on the planet?” crowd for this, however I don’t see Elon Musk considering outdoors of the usual automotive trade field very far. Tesla’s automobiles are nonetheless regular automobiles, simply with totally different powertrains. The Boring Firm was imagined to massively innovate driving with tunnels, however these are simply the identical freeways even when they’re underground. Even self driving automobiles (assuming they really achieve that standing) are nonetheless automobiles.

I don’t imply this in any type of an insulting method, however Elon Musk is de facto extra of an Edison than a Nikola Tesla. The world completely wants Edisons, as a result of you possibly can’t change the world for those who’re losing away in a lodge room any individual else paid for pining for the unrequited psychic love of one of many pigeons outdoors. However, being good at placing offers collectively and making expertise work in the actual world in opposition to horrible odds isn’t the identical as really innovating and pioneering radical new concepts that depart in vital methods from the established order.

If automakers would experiment extra with non-car approaches to electrified transportation, they could discover methods to beat Tesla at completely totally different video games that Tesla isn’t even taking part in. However, this can require large companies and play-it-safe traders to noticeably take into account issues like three-wheeled automobiles, higher types of micromobility, higher interfacing between non-public transportation and transit, or presumably eliminating the necessity for transportation in some areas.

Assumption #2: The Want For Velocity

One of many major benefits of automobiles is how shortly they’ll get the job achieved. You get into them in your driveway, lot, or storage and get going instantly by yourself schedule. You drive them at or a bit of above the pace restrict. Stopping is dangerous. Going 80 MPH is nice. Charging instances higher than gas-pumping instances are dangerous.

However, does everyone really want all of that pace?

To be clear, I’m not pushing some terrible “imaginative and prescient zero” or “you’ll personal nothing and be comfortable” agenda right here. I feel the terminally-online urbanist strategy to this stinks as a result of it leaves drivers feeling like any individual took one thing away from them, which in flip results in “throw the bums out” and hitting Ctrl+Z on such insurance policies after the following election. I’m actually, actually not asking the transportation equal of “Why do you want an AR-15?” right here.

I feel we have to ask this basic query not as a result of pace is dangerous and we wish to take the pace away, however as a result of many individuals would possibly worth different issues greater than pace. For instance, I’d personally be very pleased with a sluggish EV that has a mattress, a toilet, and a kitchenette. Bonus factors if it could possibly drive me locations whereas I sleep or watch YouTube movies in regards to the nature of the universe or perhaps write articles.

It might be doable to construct radically totally different automobiles which are cheap and environment friendly, however supply one thing individuals love greater than pace. Why? As a result of pace is simply one other type of effectivity, simply in 4 dimensions. It’s additionally one other type of consolation, and even cash (time is cash).

Assumption #3: The Superiority Of Battery-Electrical Automobiles

Earlier than I query this assumption, I wish to be clear that I’m not speaking about reverting to fossil fuels, even partially (ex PHEVs). Simply as EVs are higher than ICE and hybrid automobiles, there could also be different applied sciences that might be higher nonetheless at transferring individuals and issues round as wanted. And, no, I’m not speaking about hydrogen except there’s a serious effectivity and anti-greenwashing breakthrough.

Whoever figures out that even higher factor first goes to be the following Tesla, or perhaps the following Microsoft or Apple. Or, perhaps even the following section of human civilization. Who is aware of. However, if it’s a fair cleaner expertise, we’d undoubtedly cowl it right here.

Featured picture: “Leaving The Opera In The 12 months 2000” by Albert Robida, late nineteenth century portray. Public Area.