Talking at The Ocean Collective Summit in Singapore on Thursday, Fabien Cousteau, grandson of celebrated oceanographer Jacque Cousteau, mentioned he was “trepidatious” about an financial system being constructed round intangible property such because the averted destruction of mangroves, seagrasses and coral reefs.
Blue carbon credit – like some other kind of carbon credit score – allow corporations to offset their local weather air pollution by shopping for a credit score that represents a discount or removing of emissions, as an illustration a mangrove replanting scheme or a seagrass meadow safety venture.
The blue carbon market – which is projected to be value US$190 billion by 2030 – wanted requirements that “respect the long-term viability of nature,” Cousteau mentioned.
Verra, the world’s largest carbon credit score certifier, presently has but to develop requirements for ocean-based carbon tasks, though the verifier is engaged on establishing a blue carbon customary.
Cousteau mentioned {that a} common downside with assigning financial worth to pure ecosystems is that nature doesn’t all the time meet investor expectations for a fast return on funding (ROI), and the pursuit of short-term financial achieve is the reason for lots of the issues that bedevil the ocean, equivalent to overfishing and air pollution.
Placing an financial worth on saving an ecosystem is “a slippery slope,” he mentioned, including that there was a threat of marine assets being undervalued as actors search to “take the lion’s share of a pure useful resource checking account.”
“The issue with that [putting an economic value on nature] is, there are not any bailout loans [when a natural resource depletes]. Nature doesn’t work just like the Nasdaq. The administration [of marine resources] needs to be very completely different,” he informed Eco-Enterprise on the sidelines of the occasion.
“
Nature doesn’t work just like the Nasdaq.
Fabien Cousteau, founder, Proteus Ocean Group and the Fabien Cousteau Ocean Studying Heart
Cousteau used deep-sea mining for instance of the place unfavourable externalities should not being factored into an financial exercise within the pursuit of “fast ROI”. Supporters of deep-sea mining argue that the ocean ground should be exploited to acquire the vital minerals wanted to satisfy hovering demand for clear power applied sciences.
“We all know little or no concerning the deep-sea ecoystem. The outcomes of mining should not being factored into the calculation. There is no such thing as a mitigation plan [for deep-sea mining impacts],” he mentioned, including that injury to the seabed might be irreparable.
He mentioned that the argument that deep-sea mining might be executed sustainably – mining corporations declare that polymetallic nodules might be scooped off the seabed with minimal disruption to the benthic ecosytem – was “reckless”.
“What provides us the concept deep-sea mining might be sustainably and gained’t have an effect?” he mentioned.
Cousteau cited the current discovery of “darkish oxygen” produced by polymetallic nodules – analysis that has been disputed by pro-mining lobbyists – as a cause why extra analysis is required to find out the affect of deep-sea extraction. Nations and civic society teams are cut up on whether or not deep-sea mining ought to proceed. Rules for commercial-scale extraction are nonetheless being negotiated.
Cousteau mentioned deep-sea mining is “economically inefficient” and landfills introduced humanity with a viable various to ocean-floor extraction for transition minerals equivalent to nickel, cobalt and platinum. “Why aren’t we reusing the supplies that we’ve already mined?” he mentioned.
Although cautious of the blue carbon market as a mechanism to guard ocean assets, Cousteau, who’s elevating funds for an underwater analysis station venture known as Proteus, acknowledged that marine conservation is critically underfinanced.
The Sustainable Improvement Purpose (SDG) that represents ocean safety – life beneath water – is the least funded of all of the SDGs – and progress in the direction of reaching SDG 14 has regressed as issues equivalent to overfishing, air pollution and ocean acidification have intensified.
Whereas an estimated US$175 billion per 12 months is required to realize SDG14 by 2030, solely round US$10 billion a 12 months is presently allotted to ocean conservation. In accordance with the Asian Improvement Financial institution, whereas the blue economic system contributes trillions to the worldwide economic system, solely 1 per cent of worldwide finance flows to the ocean-based economic system.
Cousteau highlighted that funding for area exploration far exceeds the finances for ocean exploration, although the ocean holds huge untapped potential for the invention of life-saving medicines and different assets. NASA’s finances is 25 instances bigger than US federal spend on ocean analysis, and solely 5 per cent of the ocean has been explored, he famous.
Cousteau’s feedback got here the day after marine scientists known as on governments taking part within the coming United Nations Biodiversity Convention (COP16) in Colombia subsequent week to ramp up funding to analysis ocean acidification.
Key targets of COP16 embrace conserving 30 per cent of the world’s ocean by 2030, and mobilising extra capital from the personal sector to fund marine safety. Up to now, governments have contributed 83 per cent of worldwide nature finance.
Talking at The Ocean Collective Summit, Dr Meri Rosich, chief government of Singapore-based sustainability consultancy Oceanony, famous a 91 per cent improve within the variety of startups targeted on tackling marine sustainability points since 2019, because the blue economic system features traction amongst buyers.
Southeast Asia, one of many world’s most ocean-dependent regional economies, accounts for 16 per cent of ocean-driven startups within the pipeline, in line with 2020 information, in comparison with market chief Europe (52 per cent) and the USA (20 per cent).
“Asean is accelerating [in developing ocean-based startups], however not quick sufficient. It must be a part of the world the place way more is invested in the way forward for the ocean,” Rosich mentioned.
Asean economies derive 30 per cent of their revenue from ocean-based actions, with Thailand, Indonesia and Malaysia the area’s most ocean-dependent economies, she famous.
