Are Electrical Automotive Gross sales Slowing Or Accelerating? Audi & BMW Have Completely different Solutions

Join each day information updates from CleanTechnica on e-mail. Or observe us on Google Information!

In case you learn the headlines as of late, you would possibly suppose electrical automotive gross sales have gone over a cliff, as prospects pile into typical hybrids much like the Toyota Prius that has been round now in a single type or one other for nearly 30 years. Particularly in the US, the place all the things from the way to cook dinner hamburgers to the intercourse lifetime of singers has develop into a cultural battleground, the mainstream press is awash with headlines declaring the EV revolution over and accomplished with. The reality, nonetheless, is somewhat extra nuanced. Audi says its electrical automotive gross sales for the Q8 have cratered whereas BMW is crowing about its latest electrical automotive gross sales success. Such divergence is perplexing, since each firms cater to principally the identical clientele — rich drivers who count on to be pampered in each respect.

Audi To Shutter Belgian Manufacturing unit That Makes Q8 Fashions

In a press launch dated July 9, 2024, Audi mentioned it’s witnessing a worldwide decline in buyer orders within the electrical luxurious class phase. The decline impacts the Q8 e-tron and Q8 Sportback e-tron electrical automotive fashions produced in Brussels. The corporate is due to this fact contemplating the early finish of manufacturing at that manufacturing facility and the Board of Administration of Audi Brussels has knowledgeable the Firm Council of its intention to hold out a restructuring of that manufacturing facility.

The Q8 e-tron marked the beginning of electrical mobility for Audi in 2018, the corporate says, and it ran very efficiently worldwide for a few years. With the ramp-up of the brand new fashions primarily based on the forthcoming Premium Platform Electrical, the corporate is now seeing a drop in demand for the Q8 e-tron, and a pointy drop in incoming orders.

There are structural challenges on the Brussels website. The issue format is tough to alter as a result of its location near the town heart. There are additionally excessive logistics prices. Total, this results in excessive manufacturing prices in Brussels in comparison with different websites. Following an intensive evaluation of the market state of affairs and the final situations on the Brussels website, Audi is contemplating the early finish of manufacturing of the Q8 e-tron mannequin sequence. So, maybe it isn’t really a few lack of demand for electrical automotive fashions at Audi as it’s that the manufacturing facility chosen is out of date and unable to supply vehicles in a approach that’s aggressive with different producers. (Shhh ….. don’t even take into consideration dragging Chinese language vehicles into this dialog.) If in truth the manufacturing facility in Brussels, which has been producing vehicles since 1949, will get shuttered, will probably be the primary Volkswagen Group facility in Europe to ever undergo that destiny.

Closing the Belgium manufacturing facility is “a doable indicator of upcoming restructuring actions throughout the European automotive business in coming years,” Jefferies analyst Philippe Houchois mentioned in a observe to shoppers not too long ago. Based on Bloomberg, prime tier OEM suppliers akin to Bosch, Continental, and ZF are also embarking on main value chopping drives which have led to the dismissal of hundreds of staff.

Subsequent yr, extra stringent emissions limits take impact within the EU. Patrick Hummel, a UBS analyst, wrote in a report Thursday that he estimates the corporate might want to enhance battery-electric automobile gross sales by about 50% from final yr to subsequent yr. “This might develop into expensive in a market that exhibits little urge for food for BEVs,” Hummel wrote, estimating that VW might take a €2 billion hit to earnings subsequent yr. In 2026, EU officers will evaluation the feasibility of plans to successfully ban gross sales of combustion vehicles by the center of the subsequent decade.

The roughly 3,000 staff on the Audi manufacturing facility in Belgium will study their destiny quickly, with a choice on the precise nature of the restructuring anticipated by the top of this yr. The end result might boil right down to easy arithmetic, with autoworker labor charges in Belgium estimated to be about 2.8 instances larger than these in Hungary, the place BYD is organising an electrical automotive manufacturing facility. The corporate confirmed this week it has additionally agreed to construct a plant in Turkey, which equally provides decrease labor prices and has a commerce settlement with the EU.

Gene Munster, a managing accomplice at Deepwater Asset Administration, posted Wednesday on X that the potential closure of the Brussels manufacturing facility shouldn’t be learn as an indictment in opposition to electrification. “I see it as Volkswagen being selective round its EV investments. I nonetheless imagine electrification is a greater strategy to transfer given it’s extra environment friendly than fuel.”

BMW Enjoys A Surge In Electrical Automotive Gross sales

The information about electrical automotive gross sales is sunny at BMW. The Bavaria primarily based firm mentioned in a press launch on July 10, 2024, that within the first half of this yr, it delivered 179,557 battery electrical autos, a 34 % enhance over the identical interval final yr. Total, the BMW model grew by +2.3% in comparison with final yr, with 1,096,486 items offered within the first half of the yr.

“Within the first six months of the yr, we noticed double digit development of our [electric car] gross sales from the higher premium phase,” mentioned Jochen Goller, member of the Board accountable for Buyer, Manufacturers, Gross sales. “Regardless of a difficult market atmosphere, we elevated gross sales for the BMW model within the first half of the yr, due to our engaging product portfolio. The robust dedication of our BMW Group workers and our sturdy international retail community have made a major contribution on this regard,” he mentioned.

The Takeaway

The dialogue right here is just not a lot about what is going on to electrical automotive gross sales as it’s how German manufacturers are going to compete in opposition to international opponents, principally Chinese language manufacturers. If the price of labor in Hungary is a few third of what it’s in Belgium, that’s clearly a long run drawback. For the time being, the Chinese language firms are content material to focus on the decrease finish of the market, however that gained’t final perpetually. The underside line is that the electrical automotive revolution goes simply nice — for Chinese language producers. Everybody else continues to be just about behind the eight ball and struggling to remain afloat. There’s little question about it; fascinating instances for the auto business lie forward.