We not too long ago printed a overview of how China’s main corporations are disclosing greenhouse fuel emissions. Right here we summarise our findings and supply suggestions to firms.
We discovered that just about 80 per cent of main corporations will not be but disclosing any Scope 3 emissions, which means oblique emissions alongside their worth chain.
Our recommendation for them contains reporting such emissions in addition to the calculation methodology and information sources they use. They need to set emissions targets alongside clear motion plans for attaining them. And they need to work with firms throughout their provide chain to make sure it turns into zero-carbon.
A urgent problem
Within the first 9 months of 2024, the worldwide common floor air temperature was 1.54°C above the pre-industrial stage. The aim of the Paris Settlement is to maintain the long-term common beneath 1.5°C. Present nationwide insurance policies worldwide may see an increase of 3.1°C by the top of the century.
As listed corporations might account for over 40 per cent of worldwide greenhouse fuel emissions, their decarbonisation is a key a part of local weather governance. Emissions within the worth chains of these corporations – generally known as Scope 3 emissions – have grow to be an impediment to goal-setting and disclosures.
Efforts by Chinese language corporations on this regard are solely simply beginning to get consideration. Lower than 1 / 4 of the 667 main Chinese language firms that we sampled in our latest overview disclosed any Scope 3 emissions in 2024.
“
Firms can’t lower their Scope 3 emissions alone. Cooperation is critical to construct stronger zero-carbon worth chains.
From in-house operations to the worth chain
At Carbon Thoughts, we chosen all 667 firms from the CSI 300 Index, H shares, and the Cling Seng Composite LargeCap Index (HSLI), representing the biggest and most influential listed firms in China.
Our analysis discovered that 84 per cent of these corporations have been disclosing Scope 1 and a couple of emissions, but solely 22 per cent have been revealing Scope 3 emissions. Companies on the HSLI have been doing higher than common, with a disclosure price of 51 per cent, in comparison with 21 per cent on the CSI 300 Index. That is due partly to variations within the sustainability disclosure guidelines throughout the exchanges.
Globally, 47 per cent of listed firms disclosed not less than some upstream Scope 3 emissions within the first eight months of 2024, accompanied by 28 per cent for downstream, in line with analysis by Morgan Stanley Capital Worldwide. So, China’s listed corporations are lagging badly on local weather disclosure and must work onerous to catch up.
In 2023, the Worldwide Sustainability Requirements Board issued its first Worldwide Monetary Reporting Requirements, IFRS S1 and IFRS S2. These made clear that corporations should disclose sustainability-related dangers and alternatives, and associated data. This contains reporting on company emissions, equivalent to Scope 3. That offered corporations all over the world with a transparent framework, placing carbon accounting and reporting on a extra standardised footing.
For Chinese language corporations, 2024 noticed a shift from voluntary to obligatory sustainability disclosures: in April, the three main inventory exchanges – Shanghai, Shenzhen and Beijing – printed steering on sustainability reporting, encouraging corporations to make Scope 3 disclosures.
On the identical time, the Hong Kong Inventory Alternate toughened up its obligatory necessities, setting out a staged implementation of the ISSB guidelines, which means Scope 3 disclosures would grow to be required for all HSLI corporations from 2026.
Then, on 10 December, the Hong Kong authorities printed its Roadmap on Sustainability Disclosure, requiring publicly accountable entities – outlined as listed firms and a few monetary establishments – to undertake ISSB requirements. By 2028, all massive, listed firms, and non-listed monetary establishments with important operations in Hong Kong, should be absolutely implementing ISSB requirements.
From accounting to disclosure to setting targets
Firms are beginning to work on making Scope 3 disclosures, however many challenges lie forward.
In keeping with our pattern, about 80 per cent of China’s main listed corporations will not be but making Scope 3 disclosures. That determine might have been even decrease if our analysis had included listed firms of all sizes.
Of these making Scope 3 disclosures, many are nonetheless doing so selectively; disclosing solely the emissions which can be simpler to calculate, equivalent to these arising from their workers’ commutes or enterprise journey. Different elements, with better influence on the corporate’s carbon footprint, are missed out.
For instance, bought services and products are a serious supply of Scope 3 emissions for many corporations. However solely 7 per cent of the corporations we checked out disclosed this information.
Such information may be calculated by the “supplier-specific” methodology, which implies amassing information from the suppliers. However it may be onerous to acquire the information this fashion. Firms usually choose to make use of “spend-based” or “average-data” strategies, which depend on industry-average “emission elements”. There are considerations in regards to the accuracy of those two strategies.
Furthermore, of the 102 monetary establishments we checked out, lower than 7 per cent disclosed emissions from their funding and financing portfolios.
A extra severe problem is a failure to reveal accounting methodologies. Most corporations don’t say which methodology they apply, or the emission elements or information sources used.
Which means a severe lack of reliability and comparability. If corporations use completely different definitions, methodologies and sources, evaluating information throughout firms turns into tougher. There may be additionally a scarcity of transparency when methodologies are adjusted, making it onerous to trace developments throughout time.
Even when disclosures are made, there may be extra work to do. The actual problem is setting robust targets and taking efficient motion to chop emissions and obtain long-term local weather targets. We discovered that lower than 5 per cent of corporations have set targets for Scope 3 emissions. Solely 3 per cent set that concentrate on at internet zero. There may be a lot work to be accomplished on accounting, disclosure after which target-setting.
Constructing a net-zero worth chain
Companies which have taken the lead on Scope 3 reporting usually become extra aggressive. Transparency and disclosures take away limitations to financing, scale back operational dangers, enhance company reputations and ship optimistic alerts to stakeholders.
To keep away from future regulatory dangers and enhance competitiveness on the worldwide market, Chinese language corporations ought to recognise the significance of Scope 3 disclosures and get to work as quickly as potential.
Primarily based on the findings of our overview, we make the next suggestions.
First, they need to undertake frequent worldwide and home accounting requirements, such because the Greenhouse Gasoline Protocol, to make sure information is correct, clear and comparable.
Second, as soon as disclosures are made, firms ought to id and prioritise these sources of emissions which have the most important influence and the best potential for change. This requires corporations not simply to give attention to numbers going up and down.
They should clarify if they’re utilizing a spend-based, average-data or supplier-specific methodology. They should clarify the place emission elements are coming from, and which emissions sources will not be but lined and why. There also needs to be a gradual enchancment in Scope 3 calculations. For instance, shifting from spend-based strategies to bodily information and provider information for main emissions sources.
Extra importantly, firms ought to set emission targets and make these concrete, with sensible and achievable timetables. They need to be benchmarked towards corporations that lead on emissions disclosures. Clear medium- and long-term targets and motion plans ought to be established, with progress frequently tracked and disclosed.
Lastly, firms can’t lower their Scope 3 emissions alone. Cooperation is critical to construct stronger zero-carbon worth chains. Firms must actively work with all components of their provide chain, selling and empowering suppliers to calculate their emissions, to spice up accuracy of the corporate’s personal Scope 3 information.
When emissions hotspots are recognized wherever alongside the worth chain, firms ought to share data and cooperate on innovation with stakeholders to sort out these. This may promote the event and software of recent inexperienced know-how and options, accelerating the low-carbon transition of all the system.
This text was initially printed on Dialogue Earth beneath a Inventive Commons licence.
