Because the oldest renewable vitality useful resource, hydropower is well-established as a dependable supply of dispatchable vitality. But, it’s typically neglected and brought as a right. It’s generally believed that hydro’s potential is tapped out within the U.S., however many alternatives exist so as to add capability at non-powered dams and on repowering initiatives.
Hydropower installations worldwide have been more and more impacted by drought situations. The World Financial Discussion board in a current report famous that whereas hydro for a few years has offered many of the globe’s renewable vitality, its output has slowed as a result of results of local weather change, together with what the Worldwide Vitality Company (IEA) calls “erratic” rainfall. The IEA has stated world funding in hydropower era capability has fallen previously few years, and the group expects that development will proceed.
 |
|
1. Chinese language officers stated the Baihetan Hydropower Station, the world’s second-largest hydro dam with 16 GW of era capability, represents an funding of about $34 billion. Courtesy: China Three Gorges Corp. |
Regardless of that, new initiatives—together with giant installations—are being constructed. China and the U.S. in recent times have skilled drops within the proportion of hydro as a part of these nations’ era combine, however China for its half continues to spend money on hydroelectricity as a part of that nation’s technique to extend all types of energy era. China is house to many of the largest hydropower dams on this planet, led by Three Gorges Dam, a 22.5-GW behemoth that has produced energy since 2003. Subsequent is the Baihetan hydropower station (Determine 1), a 16-GW facility that grew to become totally operational in 2021.
Local weather Change Impacts Hydro
Chinese language officers, although, earlier this yr stated the nation’s hydro era has been primarily flat for the previous three years regardless of a number of new giant energy stations coming on-line, together with the Lijiaxia Hydropower Station No. 5, one of many world’s largest hydropower vegetation in a dual-row turbine format. That facility entered operation in October of final yr. Officers in China have acknowledged the necessity to proceed to help hydropower, whilst extended drought has markedly diminished river flows within the southwestern a part of the nation.
“Hydropower era critically is dependent upon how a lot water runs in rivers and therefore hydro climatological situations. Within the many years to return, there are seemingly extra frequent and extreme droughts globally, threatening sustainable hydropower operations and installations,” stated Dr. Hong-Yi Li, affiliate professor of civil and environmental engineering on the College of Houston. Li informed POWER, “To deal with this problem, different types of renewable vitality resembling photo voltaic are worthy of extra consideration than ever, significantly for these locations that already typically expertise water shortages.” China has actually acknowledged this; the nation added 226 GW of recent energy additional producing capability final yr, with 129 GW from photo voltaic, 39 GW from thermal, 33 GW from wind, and eight GW from hydro, in keeping with the Nationwide Vitality Administration.
Dimitrios Kalliontzis, assistant professor of civil and environmental engineering on the College of Houston, informed POWER: “Hydropower accounts for greater than 25% of the renewable electrical energy era in america. The danger hydropower is going through underlines the necessity to rethink, adapt, and remodel. Whereas drought is a risk to hydropower amenities, local weather change and the related sea degree rise might create alternatives to adapt current applied sciences to the offshore marine surroundings, harvesting tidal streams, currents, and even waves. Whereas offshore harvesting remains to be within the early phases, it may doubtlessly compensate or exceed the present hydropower provide.”
Ember, an vitality think-tank primarily based within the UK, final yr reported that world output of hydropower had a historic drop within the first half of 2023. The group stated drought situations led to an 8.5% lower in world hydro output throughout that interval; China accounted for about 75% of the worldwide decline. The IEA has stated hydropower ultimately shall be overtaken by photo voltaic and wind vitality output, although the company doesn’t anticipate that to occur for at the least one other decade. The group stated a slowing of the trade’s development places world net-zero targets in jeopardy. The Worldwide Renewable Vitality Company reported that hydropower era capability should double by 2050 for the world to stay on monitor to restrict world warming to 1.5C by mid-century.
John Stranne, analysis affiliate, Nordic and Baltic Energy Markets at Aurora Vitality Analysis, informed POWER: “Elevated variation in climate resulting from local weather change, with extra frequent droughts and floods, will improve the extent of uncertainties for hydropower operations. Primarily, the weekly, month-to-month, and seasonably valuation of water—which ends up in harder optimization and diminished system effectivity. Storage vegetation plan their conduct a number of months and even years prematurely, estimating when they need to contribute how a lot to the electrical energy market and at which hours of the day and durations of the yr, the place the system advantages probably the most. If climate patterns, and correspondingly hydro inflows, turn into tougher to foretell, it might result in modified bidding conduct available on the market, doubtlessly growing weekly spreads, or value volatility.”
Investments Flowing to Hydropower Initiatives
The U.S. Division of Vitality (DOE) in a 2023 market report stated that incentives approved within the Bipartisan Infrastructure Legislation and the Inflation Discount Act (IRA), together with tax credit, “are anticipated to stimulate funding in upgrades to the present [U.S.] fleet and development of recent hydropower and PSH [pumped storage hydro] initiatives within the coming years. Nevertheless, they could have contributed to the decline in exercise in 2021–2022 due to plant homeowners ready for full steerage on the implementation of those incentives (e.g., which sorts of initiatives would qualify, particulars on wage, apprenticeship, and home content material necessities) to make any new capital funding selections.”
Don Erpenbeck, vp and world sector chief of Hydropower & Dams at Stantec, an engineering companies agency, informed POWER: “The U.S. hydropower market continues to be very sturdy for engineering and for capital initiatives’ work. Nevertheless, it’s barely completely different than folks assume it’s… 90% of the capital spend within the U.S. is round hydropower refurbishment, dam refurbishment, and environmental initiatives which can be the results of ongoing Federal Vitality Regulatory Fee license compliance or different environmental enhancements.”
Erpenbeck stated Stantec is at present engaged on greater than 20 GW of repowering within the U.S. alone. “That’s principally within the powerhouses and the powertrain gear, but in addition consists of the upgrades to dams, spillways, and different main civil infrastructure components. It’s a big, multibillion-dollar development market total. The U.S. fleet, normally, is being modernized to extend their flexibility of operations with all of the completely different renewables coming onto the facility grid. The hydropower fleet has typically gone from working at a relentless energy—possibly beginning/stopping twice every week—to beginning and stopping typically eight to 10 instances per day on every unit. And inside these begins and stops, vegetation are working from most to minimal energy swings to manage the grid. A hydropower plant’s functionality to manage the grid by way of versatile operations is completely taken as a right. However discuss to any operator in a balancing authority management heart and they’re going to inform you how beneficial the hydro items are. However it’s accelerating the getting older means of the present older fleet.”
Lizzie Bonahoom, analysis affiliate at Aurora Vitality Analysis, stated hydropower nonetheless needs to be thought of necessary to the buildout of renewable vitality assets. “Hydro applied sciences account for simply 28% of put in renewables capability as we speak within the U.S., down from 54% a decade in the past,” stated Bonahoom, who referenced U.S. totals of 99 GW of hydropower and 184 GW of whole renewable vitality era capability in 2014, ranges that are actually at 101 GW and 360 GW, respectively.
“These [hydro] initiatives are usually older, with solely 3% of capability coming on-line since 2000. The three several types of large-scale hydropower throughout the U.S. are typical hydropower [impoundment] at 79 GW, pumped storage at 22 GW, and run of river [hydrokinetic or diversion] at slightly below 1 GW. Over half [50 GW out of 79 GW] of current typical hydro is situated within the West, significantly Washington, California, and Oregon, whereas, most pumped storage is situated within the South [10 GW],” she stated.
Bonahoom additional famous, “Totally different income streams and subsidy constructions can be found to new construct hydropower initiatives throughout the U.S. All are supported by federal funding tax credit, which below IRA provisions might attain as much as a 50% low cost on whole challenge CAPEX [capital expenditure]. Typical hydropower and run of river are additionally eligible for the manufacturing tax credit score, a variable subsidy primarily based on electrical energy era. Further help is obtainable for hydro within the Bipartisan Infrastructure Legislation, which goals to enhance environmental requirements and operation of current amenities, with out extending help to new amenities.”
Markets and Competing Applied sciences Differ by Location
Bonahoom stated there are regional variations on the subject of U.S. hydropower. “On a extra granular degree, all markets within the U.S. have completely different designs and are influenced by native and state insurance policies along with federal coverage. For instance, hydro would have a tendency to profit from capability market funds in markets with capability funds, resembling CAISO’s [California Independent System Operator’s] Useful resource Adequacy or PJM’s Reliability Pricing Mannequin. In Texas’ market, ERCOT [Electric Reliability Council of Texas], the place there isn’t any capability market, hydro is eligible to take part in smaller ancillary companies, resembling spinning reserve.”
Bonahoom famous the influence of drought on the hydropower market, and the way that may restrict funding. “Regardless of availability of federal tax credit and varied different income streams, there has solely been 3.3 GW of hydro made operational for the reason that yr 2010 [all of it conventional], which is small in comparison with onshore wind [116 GW], photo voltaic PV [97 GW], and battery [17 GW] additions in the identical time-frame,” stated Bonahoom.
“Except for excessive prices, drought danger presents a major barrier to growth of extra hydropower on the system: California’s energy marketplace for instance is especially prone to drought and a poor water yr can cut back hydro output by roughly 10 TWh, roughly 5% of the ISO’s demand in 2023,” she stated. “Excessive upfront prices of creating hydro have helped to hamper growth. That is mirrored in investor curiosity throughout aggressive ISOs; solely 3.1 GW of recent pumped storage and 1.7 GW of typical hydro is at present below growth, versus 586 GW of battery storage, 584 GW of photo voltaic PV, and 213 GW of onshore wind.”
Bonahoom stated that regardless of missing investor curiosity, there’s a rising want for dispatchable clear era within the U.S. to enhance rising intermittent renewables era. “Pumped hydro particularly is in a very good place to offer worth, ‘charging’ when energy costs are low and there may be enough era on the system, and discharging when the grid is tighter, which is able to extra typically coincide with the solar setting,” she famous.
David Pretyman, senior associate of Vitality and Utilities at West Monroe, a consultancy group, stated, “It’s true that hydropower outputs within the American West have been under common this yr and final. Nevertheless, the variability of a altering local weather can also suggest that the moist seasons might turn into wetter, and the dry seasons might turn into drier. This might doubtlessly destabilize energy costs and the general system make-up in the long run. Dueling proposals and divided allegiances amongst market contributors on the way forward for a West-wide regional transmission group might additional complicate issues,” he stated.
 |
|
2. The Grand Coulee Dam is the most important hydroelectric facility and largest energy plant of any type within the U.S., with greater than 6.8 GW of era capability. The dam is situated on the Columbia River, about 90 miles west of Spokane, Washington. Supply: U.S. Bureau of Reclamation |
Pretyman continued: “As an illustration, Bonneville Energy Administration, which markets wholesale electrical energy from lots of the giant federal hydro amenities within the Northwest [including the Grand Coulee Dam, the largest hydro dam in the U.S. with more than 6.8 GW of generation capacity, Figure 2], helps a day-ahead market proposal from Southwest Energy Pool. In the meantime, California and a number of other surrounding utilities have signed on in help of a proposal to increase California’s market preparations extra broadly to the West. The last word framework could have important implications for a way hydropower is valued on the grid.”
Including New Hydropower Capability Can Be Troublesome
Pretyman additionally referenced the market dynamics of the U.S. Northeast, telling POWER, “The fact is that the U.S. has largely exhausted its accessible hydropower assets, with new dam proposals typically going through opposition from environmental teams. This opposition is partly driving investor {dollars} towards transmission options. As an illustration, within the Northeast, the Champlain Hudson Energy Specific HVDC [high-voltage direct-current] transmission line is about to ship hydropower from Quebec to serve the New York Metropolis load heart with substantial quantities of fresh vitality. This challenge has been in growth for over 20 years. Nevertheless, one other proposed line, supposed to carry hydropower to the New England space, was just lately canceled regardless of receiving federal backing. The problem lies to find a method to entry clear, agency energy the place photo voltaic and wind alone are inadequate.”
The biggest hydro challenge at present deliberate within the U.S. is the Leslie D. Thatcher pumped storage facility, in keeping with International Information. The Thatcher PSH challenge, which might be situated in Michigan, is being designed with a complete capability of just about 3.5 GW. Hydropower Freeway is the challenge developer.
Erpenbeck informed POWER, “Within the U.S., the brand new hydropower market goes to be centered on pumped storage hydropower. Within the vitality transition, the worth of electrical energy storage, and significantly long-duration storage, is dominated by pumped storage, the place over 90% of the U.S. electrical energy storage capability is at present within the current pumped storage fleet. But it surely might want to improve and doubtlessly even double to help all the brand new photo voltaic and wind initiatives. Pumped storage could be very dispatchable, however not like batteries, that are DC energy with inverters, these are giant synchronous machines which have giant quantities of inertia and add stability and reliability to the grid when in comparison with inverter-based assets. Pumped storage may also run as a synchronous condenser as required by the grid.”
The DOE in a March report wrote: “Hydropower’s longstanding fame as a dependable supply of vitality and storage might sarcastically be one of many causes folks typically assume it’s ‘tapped out’ of funding alternatives, however this isn’t the case. Removed from being tapped out, hydropower, together with pumped storage hydropower, nonetheless has huge potential for development, significantly for small- and medium-sized initiatives [or those that produce up to 30 MW of power].”
The DOE famous that lower than 3% of the greater than 90,000 dams within the U.S. produce energy, and stated that there are “1000’s of non-powered dams providing wonderful alternatives for funding. As well as, dams that do at present produce energy can typically be up to date to extend capability. There are additionally thousands and thousands of miles of waterways, together with each rivers and canals, that may be utilized for in-stream hydropower.”
“The U.S. ought to positively be investing extra into new, renewable hydropower growth, in addition to the present fleet,” stated Erpenbeck. “On the present vegetation, the bigger vegetation have been getting funding as a result of they’re so beneficial. However the smaller initiatives have been struggling. Many of those are very outdated initiatives—greater than 80 years outdated—that had been a part of an industrial advanced, like a pulp and paper mill, the place the megawatts aren’t all that giant out of the power. Nevertheless, the power itself and the dams present leisure lakes and flood management, and the facility mainly pays for all these public advantages. These are the initiatives which have been sorely uncared for and struggling to seek out the right funds to place again into the initiatives. By way of new initiatives, the very fact is that lots of the greatest typical hydro challenge websites have been constructed. Nevertheless, there are lots of dams within the U.S. that also don’t have hydropower on them, over 80,000, and a few of these could possibly be developed if we are able to discover websites the place there are minimal impacts to powering the dams,” he stated.
“I’ve labored within the hydropower trade my complete profession and one of many issues that I inform folks is that each hydropower challenge is an area vacationer attraction, a leisure space, a boating and fishing haven, in addition to a instrument for flood management, navigation, or water provide—all of that along with being a renewable energy challenge,” stated Erpenbeck. “Lots of the initiatives have guests’ facilities and museums. I can’t title every other energy challenge that has these items, and they’re widespread on many hydropower initiatives. We used to say these initiatives are designed for 100 years, however the actuality is that these initiatives are ‘endlessly property’ as certainly one of my shoppers refers to them.”
Erpenbeck continued: “Along with lengthy life and native vacationer advantages, many of those initiatives are over 90% environment friendly. And when designed accurately they are often an environmentally optimistic power locally. Sure, hydropower is an older confirmed know-how—however was additionally the primary renewable useful resource developed within the U.S. The know-how has been upgraded through the years, a lot in order that the brand new initiatives are very completely different than the outdated historic initiatives. However, but, they’re taken as a right as a result of they’re a legacy asset. We have to have a look at the long run and embody what works. We as an influence trade have to get again to occupied with a number of bottom-line decision-making and have a longer-term imaginative and prescient than the following 5 years. As a substitute, take into consideration the following 50 years, and within the case of hydropower, the following 100-plus years.”
—Darrell Proctor is a senior affiliate editor for POWER.
