As we slide inexorably into the clutches of Soviet-style cultural narrative management and thought prevention courtesy of ‘fact-checking’ establishments and their oddly subjective ‘truth books’, I provide the next conundrum as a hurled wrench into the cogs of the greasy gears of the thought police:
Solar energy might quickly grow to be a beautiful factor for humanity.
As a heretical author on an oil/gasoline centric web site – most certainly quickly to be flagged by governmental decree and definition a writhing pit of misinformation or disinformation (take your decide – invoice C-11 & spawn received’t cut up hairs) – sure, I provide a ringing endorsement for solar energy.
Not as a blanket answer in fact; I could also be heretical however I’m not insane. And never as an olive department to those who suppose photo voltaic can grow to be some type of spine of {the electrical} system. The keenness herein for photo voltaic is in reference to the expertise as a possible constructing block for an entire different side of civilization that’s extra desperately wanted by an element of ten than the present collective spastic heave that’s our conflict on carbon emissions.
Solar energy could show to be a wonderful answer to one of many world’s most appreciable issues: a scarcity of potable water.
Water desalination from the solar just isn’t precisely new expertise, it seemingly has been round longer than the world’s oldest occupation. (Exhausting to pin that time in historical past precisely however hey it offers context that perks up the ears of most individuals. Suffice it to say that photo voltaic distillation has been round for hundreds of years.)
My inbox, spanning e mail and social media (taking a look at you Twitter) appears to be full of one in every of two issues nowadays – some trendy type of prostitution (aw, look who began following me…wait a minute, is it essential to point out everybody that…) or one thing to do with renewable vitality as an answer to emissions. Each have mastered the artwork of PR, each make stunning claims, each promise an excellent time for subsequent to nothing, and each are going to get you in bother.
Nevertheless, out of that morass did truly seem some eye-catching info (not the porn – it is likely to be an eyeful nevertheless it’s not info). A Saudi Arabian agency named Acwa Energy is without doubt one of the many who peppers me with information releases, and one in every of them someway stood out within the circulate: Acwa Energy introduced the Hassyan sea water desalination plant that may use solar energy to provide 180 million gallons of desalinated water, per day.
Massive wild numbers are troublesome to contextualize on their very own, so right here’s a visible: an Olympic sized swimming pool, 165 ft lengthy and 56 ft extensive, holds slightly below 500,000 US gallons. This Acwa Energy venture might fill 360 of them, day-after-day.
Of much more significance is that the worth of such desalination has been tumbling. In 1970, the fee for reverse osmosis desalinated water was about $5 per cubic meter. By 2005, the fee had fallen to about $1/m3. The Acwa Energy venture pegs the fee at $0.37. My current Metropolis of Calgary water invoice exhibits a water value of $1.42/m3 which is about $1.03 US, or triple the worth that Acwa is supplying water at.
Take into account that falling value construction together with Acwa’s complete desalination capability. The corporate can now produce 7.6 million cubic meters per day, or two billion gallons – sufficient to fill 4,000 Olympic dimension swimming swimming pools, day-after-day.
That is fairly unbelievable information for humanity. It’s true that huge photo voltaic fields aren’t precisely environmentally pleasant, however provided that many areas wanting water have huge tracts of marginally helpful land (fly over a lot of the southwestern US and look out the window, for instance) that is likely to be a unbelievable house for solar energy if the commerce off is to fill a bunch of swimming swimming pools day-after-day, or, who is aware of, perhaps even develop some greens or irrigate some bushes.
Think about if in future huge pipelines are constructed from coastal areas inland, carrying sufficient water for cities in determined want, all at low value. Possibly the pipelines deliver sea water inland for desalination, the place huge stretches of almost empty land could possibly be utilized for photo voltaic desalination.
Photo voltaic could possibly be utilized precisely as it really works greatest – by offering a service not tied to the persistent timing calls for of shoppers. Different fuels couldn’t contact it, assuming Acwa’s economics are sound elsewhere.
Such is the trail ahead for the ‘vitality transition’; that’s how we’re going to make precise progress in utilization of renewable vitality. In actual fact, the time period ‘vitality transition’ ought to in all probability be junked, as a result of it has grow to be so loaded and politicized that it is sort of a rusted out junk-heap smoking down the freeway.
We aren’t actually transitioning away from any explicit type of vitality; a number of centuries after coal appeared as a serious industrial gas, the world now continues to set annual consumption data for the stuff. Identical as oil. Identical as pure gasoline.
You don’t should be critical scholar, solely half-interested will suffice, in vitality historical past to shortly grasp the explanation for the rise of coal, and what that low cost/straightforward gas allowed people to perform; to shortly grasp the importance of oil, and what it allowed people to do; to shortly grasp the importance of pure gasoline as some form of miraculous heating gas that allowed mass settlement in very chilly areas, that allowed manufacture of numerous issues…and on and on. Possibly solar energy has discovered its area of interest the place it may be of huge profit to humanity.
In a nutshell, that’s the story of vitality – the apparent large potential of recent developments that transfer humanity ahead not in tiny steps however in massive strides. However these strides don’t come about by abolishing the prevailing methods, until the brand new expertise is so vitally superior that it renders out of date any demand for the earlier. Discover the nuance there; a transition occurs by a draw to the brand new, not an abolition of the prevailing. The adoption of cars didn’t require the execution of horses.
Regardless of the airplay given to opponents within the media, there isn’t any grand villainy within the vitality world. The truth that each single individual depends on hydrocarbons to the extent they do (which is totally and fully) is kind of clearly the consequence of the utility of these fuels over time, not a nefarious scheme for world dominance by producers. In actual fact, if any expertise might have supplanted massive portions of hydrocarbons, it might have been nuclear energy – however most of the most fanatical anti-nuclear persons are additionally anti-hydrocarbons (Greenpeace, for instance), whereas I do know only a few oilpatch people who marketing campaign in opposition to nuclear.
Each single shopper would favor to have cheaper, cleaner vitality, however not on the expense of reliability. No menace is extra instinctually horrifying than the considered operating out of gas after we want it most. Components of the WEF crowd are even acknowledging this; Invoice Gates not too long ago identified that “For those who attempt to do local weather brute pressure, you’ll get individuals who say, ‘I like local weather however I don’t need to bear that value and cut back my lifestyle.’ “ And that’s right here within the west; within the creating world, the dialog is much extra abrupt than that.
Any ‘vitality transition’ needs to be constructed round these chilly onerous realities. Governments must cease attempting to quash sure industries simply because they’ve been led to consider that doing so is the trail ahead. It isn’t.
You would possibly ponder whether this animosity in direction of hydrocarbons is extra imagined than actual. Take into account this: Masking Local weather Now could be an affiliation of over 500 information retailers, organizations, skilled howlers, and each group of rag-tag semi-employable grad college students that has come collectively beneath the local weather banner. The group consists of such media pillars as Reuters and Newsweek.
On their Tasks web page is a venture referred to as: Local weather crimes – investigating “large oil’s complicity within the local weather disaster and makes an attempt to carry the fossil gas trade accountable.”
Hmm. Ignoring the unbelievable psychological deficiencies and dexterities required to chorus from cataloguing the advantages dropped at humanity by hydrocarbons (that’s, nearly all of them), one has to surprise why they aren’t going after “Massive Coal”. Is it as a result of the creating world would, if in an excellent temper, throw them out on their ear?
We stay silent on this bullsh*t at our peril. Not simply as an trade – the antics of those clowns will solely make reserves extra beneficial when demand is clearly so excessive – however as humanity. It’s the much less effectively off, the non-Tesla drivers, that may take it on the chin when our present hydrocarbon provide chain is pummeled into oblivion.
Please distinction their witch hunt with the truth that there isn’t any concern with talking on an oil and gas-centric web site of the advantages of photo voltaic (and hydrogen, and nuclear, and many others.) as a result of these issues aren’t the competitors most make it out to be. Seven billion persons are striving to reside like the opposite billion, and the inspiration upon which they may make progress is reasonably priced, dependable vitality.
Add within the west’s newfound fascination with AI, and knowledge facilities, and air conditioners, amongst many different power-sucking accoutrements, and it’s clear that we want all types of vitality, in as a lot amount as we will present.
It’s protected to take this concept one step additional. Take into account that the oil patch has a waste water downside; many oilfields have excessive water cuts, and that impure water incurs prices to move and dispose. What if solar energy could possibly be harnessed to distill a lot of that waste water – the method might present very beneficial new potable water sources within the parched prairies, might decrease transportation and disposal prices of waste water, and will cut back emissions related to transportation, processing and disposal of all that waste water.
I’d guess that the oil patch would wholeheartedly embrace the idea of using photo voltaic vitality lengthy earlier than the Guilbeaults of the world might embrace the worth of pure gasoline and harness it to full potential.
It must be as much as the knowledge of our leaders to recollect the miracles of the division of labour, and apply it to vitality. Not everybody in a village must be a boot maker; not each nation ought to attempt to be grasp of all industries; and a few types of vitality will work wonders in a single space however not in one other. Solar energy is a good complement to an influence grid, as much as a really restricted level, however is likely to be a game-changer within the discipline of desalination. Discover one of the best use for every area of interest. EVs is likely to be unbelievable metropolis supply autos/cabs/and many others. however would possibly by no means work within the chilly rural heartland. So what? It’s not a problem in any respect, besides that governments are having a phenomenally troublesome time accepting the truth that blanket local weather initiatives are doomed to fail, in a really painful manner.
Eventually we’ll begin coming to our senses policy-wise, however there are going to should be some wake-up calls alongside the way in which earlier than we get there.
Vitality conversations must be optimistic and, most of all, grounded in actuality. Life depends upon it. Discover out extra in “The Finish of Fossil Gasoline Madness” at Amazon.ca, Indigo.ca, or Amazon.com. Thanks!
Learn extra insightful evaluation from Terry Etam right here, or e mail Terry right here.
###
Addendum from Charles.
Wind Energy can also be a doubtlessly wonderful means to function a desalination plant, particularly when one avoids electrical technology altogether with: Direct-Pushed Wind Powered Desalination: Mechanical-Hydraulic Methods
From: Integration of Wind Vitality and Desalination Methods: A Assessment Research
6. Direct-Pushed Wind Powered Desalination: Mechanical-Hydraulic Methods
All of the methods introduced earlier than think about electrical energy because the intermediate vitality medium: the mechanical vitality of a turbine is transformed into electrical vitality, which is then used to energy the tools wanted for the desalination course of. To cut back the intermediate vitality losses, {the electrical} conversion step could be averted. That is the case of stand-alone methods the place the wind turbine is mechanically and hydraulically linked to the RO system.
Which means the generator and the digital elements are eradicated. Of their place, the rotor is mechanically linked to the shaft of the pump or compressor that drive the desalination course of. The pump and compressor could be positioned on the backside of the tower or on the floor stage, so {that a} system of gearboxes, pistons and belt transmission system is used for transmitting the movement [77,78,79,80]. One other chance is to find the compressor and the pump immediately within the nacelle [81,82,83]. In these circumstances, the fluid is pressurised immediately there, and act as a vitality switch medium. An outline of a number of sort of rotor-pump connections in wind generators with hydraulic transmission system was introduced in Chen et al. [84].
The usage of a mechanic/hydraulic transmission system deliver a number of benefits. Specifically, good performances, robustness and reliability, which might be notably enticing for distant space purposes [77,85,86]. As well as, the elimination on the generator results in a noticeable discount of weight within the nacelle. An summary of the prototype and conceptual design of wind-driven desalination methods with mechanic and hydraulic connection is introduced within the following subsection, and summarised in Desk 5.
Desk 5. Stand alone with direct mechanic–hydraulic connection.
6.1. With Intermediate Vitality Storage
One of many first prototypes of immediately linked wind-driven desalination methods was developed and examined for groundwater desalination in 1988 [77]. There, an Aermotor fan-blade windmill extracted water from a effectively. In such a wind pump, the rotational movement of the rotor is transformed by a geared mechanism to an up and down movement, that drives a pump rod contained in the effectively.
On this manner, water was pumped up the pipe at every upstroke and was delivered to stress tanks at a stress of 600–1100 kPa. The stress vessels had the position of hydraulic accumulator, as vitality storage. A solenoid valve allowed the circulate of pressurised water from the stress vessels to the membranes for the desalination course of when a pre-set stress stage was reached. A easy schematic of the system is introduced in Determine 5.
Determine 5. Schematics of the pilot venture described in [77].
The prototype was operational for 13 months, and the information collected throughout operations proved the effectiveness of such a system, although the stress losses of the system amounted as much as 52%, and the restoration price achieved values of 9–9.7%: that was very near the goal worth of 10%, however nonetheless decrease than standard desalination methods.
The plant resulted to be economically possible if in contrast with standard water manufacturing applied sciences when the capability is 500 L/d or extra, however not handy when water carting is feasible at a distance under 30–40 km. To extend the effectivity and cut back the vitality losses related to the brine stream (over 90% at 10% restoration price), the usage of an vitality restoration machine was advised. Moreover, a self regulation and system management is totally wanted, and a diesel generator or gasoline pump is critical to cowl for all the time guaranteeing potable water.
An analogous prototype was constructed and examined in Coconut Island, Hawaii [78], see Determine 6. Once more, a multivane wind pump was used to pressurised brackish water, that was saved in a hydro pneumatic flow-pressure stabiliser. Nevertheless, on this case not one however a sequence of solenoid valves are used to control the circulate to the desalination unit, opening and shutting sequentially in correspondence of various stress ranges reached within the hydro-pneumatic storage. On this manner, the working water stress is saved roughly fixed, whatever the wind speeds.
Determine 6. Schematics of the pilot venture described in [78].
Within the execution of the venture [79], the power to create totally different stress ranges was used for together with water pre-treatment within the system. Within the first stage of operation, the water stress was pretreated. Within the second stage, the pretreated water was pressurised additional for RO desalination. Moreover, a modification of the prototype was applied to let the system work additionally at totally different feed water salinities: a number of RO unit as put in parallel, every one capable of work for a selected vary of feed water salinity.
The management system measured the focus of the feed water after which sends the pretreated water to the corresponding reverse osmosis stress vessel. The prototype was then efficiently managing various wind pace and feed water concentrations. Nevertheless, each circumstances mentioned above are solely appropriate for brackish water desalination, for the reason that wind pump system just isn’t capable of rise the stress to the extent required for seawater desalination.
A stress accumulator was introduced in WindDeSalter expertise [82]. In WindDeSalter expertise, the desalination plant is immediately linked to the wind turbine, and fully built-in inside the wind turbine tower. Two totally different configurations are doable, both integration with RO desalination or with MVC, as proven in Determine 7. In each circumstances, seawater is pre-filtrated and saved in a built-in tank on the underside of the tower. From there, the prefiltrated seawater is pumped up for being desalinated.
Determine 7. Schematics of the pilot venture described in [82]: on the left, the model with reverse osmosis as desalination expertise; on the proper, the one with mechanical vapour compression.
Within the case of RO desalination, water is pumped as much as the nacelle, the place pumps linked to the rotor by way of a gearbox pressurise it and ship it to the stress accumulator and to the RO models, positioned on the tower slightly below the nacelle. The stress accumulator smoothen the stress fluctuations and the height masses, whereas a management machine regulate the pressurised quantity circulate of sea water by way of a circulate management valve, and the ability produced by the wind turbine by way of the blade pitch mechanism. Moreover, a number of pumps and RO desalination unit could be activated or deactivated relying on the obtainable wind energy.
Within the case of MVC desalination, the pre-filtrated seawater is first pre-heated, after which it’s pumped to the evapourator/condenser positioned within the high of the tower. On this case, the compressor of the MVC system is immediately linked to the rotor of the wind turbine. Then, the freshwater and the brine produced are dealt with as within the RO desalination configuration. The authors concluded that such a system is possible and value aggressive in contrast with standard applied sciences.
An modern hydro-pneumatic vitality storage system was built-in in a floating offshore wind-driven seawater desalination system in Cutajar et al. [81], in Determine 8. On this case research, a floating offshore wind turbine supported by a rigidity leg platform is immediately used for pressurising seawater. The rotational movement of the rotor is transformed in linear movement by a swash plate piston pump, changing the generator within the nacelle.
Determine 8. Schematics of the pilot venture described in [81].
The pressurised seawater is then accrued into the submersed chamber, positioned into the gravity basis of the stress leg platforms and anchored to the seabed, of a two chamber hydro-pneumatic storage. The air with which each chambers are pre-filled is then pushed trough the umbilical into the opposite, floating chamber and compressed. This manner the system is charging and the vitality is saved. When there may be not sufficient wind, as a substitute, the air within the floating chamber is allowed to broaden, pushing seawater out at excessive stress.
The pressurised seawater is then directed to the reverse osmosis module, positioned on the platform, and is desalinated. The freshwater obtained could be pumped to the shore by a booster pump, whereas the brine is recirculated in a PX ERD exchanger. The residual vitality within the brine is transmitted to a part of the pre-treated water that’s saved within the liquid piston chamber, whereas the exhausted brine is discharged into the open sea.
The paper supplies a mathematical and computational mannequin to simulate the system and analyse two circulate management schemes. The primary one acts to keep up a continuing stress to the feed circulate to the RO membranes, whereas the second goals at sustaining a continuing circulate price. Each schemes forestall the emptying or the overfilling of the decrease chamber. Outcomes from the simulation present that the proposed configuration and management schemes present an excellent smoothing of the fluctuations, with the ability to produce 33,000 m33/d with a 5 MW wind turbine and 6.5 MWh hydro-penumatic storage.
6.2. With out Vitality Storage however Direct Connection
Nevertheless, vitality storage methods enhance the preliminary value and the burden and quantity of the wind-driven desalination plant. There isn’t any vitality storage within the small prototype described by Heijman et al. [80], in Determine 9. The rotor of the multivane wind turbine is immediately linked to the shaft of the excessive stress pump of the SWRO desalination unit at floor stage, by the use of a bevel gear, a vertical shaft and a belt drive.
Determine 9. Schematics of the pilot venture described in [80].
The motor of the vitality restoration machine is mounted on the identical shaft of the excessive stress pump, due to this fact they all the time have the identical rotational pace. Because of the direct mechanical connection of the wind turbine and the pump and the absence of any intermediate storage machine, the pump pace, and so the permeate manufacturing, varies with wind. On this manner, the restoration price could be maintained mounted with out the necessity of any further regulators advert controls. Coping with variable course of situations, the prototype was capable of obtain a most restoration of 25% (in contrast with 40–50% of typical worth for seawater desalination in business methods) and a variable permeate circulate. The system features a tank for storing freshwater to cowl for the interval of wind unavailability.
The excessive stress pump changing the generator is positioned within the nacelle and immediately linked to the wind turbine rotor within the prototype described in Greco et al. [83], see Determine 10. Pre-filtrated seawater is pressurised within the nacelle and delivered partly to a SWRO desalination module for freshwater manufacturing and partly to a Pelton turbine generator for electrical energy manufacturing.
Determine 10. Schematics of the pilot venture described in [83].
An isobaric vitality restoration machine (iSave) is used to recuperate vitality from the brine, pressurising a part of the seawater. This portion of seawater is then deducted from the water that’s processed by the excessive stress pump. The prototype, that’s primarily composed of on-shelf elements, is designed for a rated desalination capability of 600 m33/d of produced water. Given the direct connection between the wind turbine rotor and of the excessive stress pump, the circulate price and the stress of the stream supplied by the latter range relying on the wind pace.
Subsequently, an operational technique is proposed to let the system function inside the limits imposed by every part, maximising freshwater and electrical energy manufacturing. The operational technique is predicated on the energetic management of the collective blade-pitch mechanism, on the opening place of the spear valve of the Pelton turbine, and on the circulate charges dealt with by the ERD.
Lastly, a brand new idea of floating wind turbine, the Wind Vitality Marine Unit WEMU, is employed for desalinating seawater in [87,88]. A WEMU is a wind turbine with vertical axis, round which rotates a semi-subermgible rotating pontoon, as a form of vertical blades construction. A WEMU is supplied of a a hydraulic transmission system, consisting of hydrostatic water pumps immediately linked to the rotor, and excessive head water generators for the manufacturing of electrical energy.
For its utility for seawater desalination, two totally different configurations are proposed, as represented in Determine 11. In [87], the WEMU is used for Multi Stage Flash distillation (MSF) desalination. The water pumped by the hydraulic transmission system of the WEMU is partly used for electrical energy manufacturing by way of a hydraulic head turbine generator. The electrical energy generated is used for heating the remaining pressurised seawater, which is than distilled within the MSF plant.
Determine 11. Schematics of the pilot venture described in [87] (on the left) and on [88], on the proper.
Warmth could be recycled from the brine and the permeate by pre-heating the feed seawater by means of warmth exchangers. In [88], as a substitute, the water pressurised by the hydraulic transmission system is directed to an RO module and desalinated. The permeate is then set to the shore. Even on this case vitality is recovered, by processing the excessive stress brine by means of a high-head hydraulic turbine generator, producing electrical energy. In keeping with the authors such a system is essentially the most promising for partially fixing the water lack downside in Northern Crimea, with the extra benefit of offering additionally electrical vitality.
Whereas the standard electrical drive transmission system is effectively subtle and predominant for wind generators, the usage of hydraulic or mechanical drive transmission methods in wind vitality remains to be within the improvement part and covers a distinct segment market. The decrease diffusion is due to this fact mirrored within the restricted variety of prototypes and research on immediately linked wind drive desalination methods. The few pilot examined or proposed have a variety of wind energy capability (from under 1 kW to eight MW) and water manufacturing capability (from under 1 m33/d as much as 864,000 m33/d), have totally different format configurations and wind turbine shapes.
Nevertheless, there’s a clear predominance of the reverse osmosis as desalination expertise. Additionally it is attention-grabbing to note that the majorities of the latest prototypes or case research are meant for offshore purposes, relatively than onshore. From the assessments and simulations introduced it’s seen that there are a number of operational technique that may be adopted to efficiently address the fluctuations of wind vitality and, as soon as the applied sciences will develop additional, the outcomes could also be promising and aggressive with respect to traditional methods.
