Built-in Campaigning Matter Week
By Mohammad Rubaiyat Rahman
Introduction
Built-in naval campaigning refers to a sequence of operations aiming to realize strategic and operational aims by means of navy, diplomatic, and non-military actions.1 Such a naval marketing campaign encompasses a number of domains and the built-in method options joint and interagency companions of the U.S. authorities.2 As emphasised within the U.S. Nationwide Protection Technique of 2022, there’s a requirement for an built-in method to realize navy benefit, improve deterrence, and deal with grey zone problem.
The demand for U.S Navy engagement within the Indo-Pacific area is stronger than at any time within the previous three a long time.3 Such urgency is well-understood upon the idea that that the naval dominance of the U.S. Navy paves the flexibility of the U.S. to venture joint energy globally. As built-in naval campaigning within the Indo-Pacific area beneficial properties traction, the U.S. Navy’s position in deterrence by denial encourages it to concentrate on countering grey zone operations. Subsequently to realize nationwide aims, the U.S. Navy requires new fleet-wide operational and campaigning ideas to compete with the grey zone exercise of opponents.
The geostrategic state of affairs within the Bay of Bengal displays the necessity for an idea of built-in naval campaigning in help of a rules-based Indo-Pacific. The importance of this maritime zone is looming bigger within the strategic calculus of the Indo-Pacific area and has change into a central area for grey zone competitors, particularly between Indian and Chinese language maritime forces.4 The grey zone competitors entrenched within the Bay of Bengal has lengthy preceded the latest requires built-in campaigning from U.S. forces.
The Bay of Bengal is a key maritime zone of curiosity and affect for the U.S. Navy to advertise regional safety and rules-based order by means of campaigning. The Bay is a key geographic crossroads between the Indian Ocean and the Pacific Ocean by means of which intensive maritime visitors transits, making the competitors over rules-based order particularly salient. The grey zone actions within the Bay of Bengal demand particular consideration from the U.S. Navy, and can demand operational innovation and partnership-building particularly tailor-made to the complexities of the native grey zone competitors. These efforts will serve the usNavy effectively in informing its broader campaigning all through the Indo-Pacific area.
China’s Grey Zone Marketing campaign within the Bay of Bengal: Appraising the State of affairs
The time period ‘grey zone’ first began to seem within the coverage paperwork of Japan and the USA.5 Grey zone conditions can confer with nearly something under the edge of high-intensity navy battle, or a big number of non-military technique of competitors. It’s elementary to any grey zone state of affairs that the adversary nation intentionally extends its grey zone efforts to realize sufficient coercive energy to undermine the goal state’s sovereign management. Within the case of focusing on littoral states, this may embrace impeding rightful financial exploitation, hampering using maritime zones for secure passage, and different unfair manipulations of norms within the maritime area.6 In different phrases, the adversary nation makes use of grey zone actions to claim their maritime pursuits on the expense of different states and the broader norms of the maritime system.7 Compared to high-end navy operations, any grey zone state of affairs naturally belongs to the low-end spectrum of warfare.8 Grey zone campaigns can even search to inflict long-term political and navy prices, facilitate a positive reinterpretation of the state of affairs with respect to public opinion, and a gradual change of circumstances and conduct in favor of the adversary nation’s coverage preferences.9
The importance of the Bay of Bengal is looming bigger within the maritime calculus of the Indo-Pacific area.10 The geostrategic significance of the Bay of Bengal11 as a crucial maritime crossroads between the Indian Ocean and the Pacific Ocean has severe implications12 for China’s multi-pronged ambitions in direction of shaping international governance.13 Primarily from the Eighties, China has been deepening relationships with the Bay’s littoral states and pulling these international locations into financial and navy partnerships.14
China’s ceaseless endeavor to penetrate into the Bay of Bengal by means of Bangladesh, Myanmar, and Sri Lanka has been a maritime safety problem to rules-based order within the Indo-Pacific area. Over latest a long time, these littoral states have relied on China for financial, navy, and infrastructure growth. China has constructed ports, roads, pipelines, and railway tracts in these littoral states. Creating maritime infrastructure and facilitating financial dependencies in littoral states operate as crucial enablers for China’s grey zone marketing campaign within the Bay of Bengal.
China’s financial relations with these littoral states have raised two issues, particularly the potential use of infrastructure for enhancing China’s navy entry within the area, and China incomes vital political leverage over the decision-making of these international locations, to the detriment of democracy and the rule of regulation. Lately, such hegemonic affect has acquired a extra virulent kind. For instance, when ASEAN introduced its outlook coverage on the Indo-Pacific, some littoral states within the Bay of Bengal opted for a cautionary response, probably reflecting how China would like they obtain the coverage declaration. The littoral states of this area are additionally reluctant to make clear their observations in direction of built-in deterrence within the Bay of Bengal.15 For instance, in Bangladesh’s outlook on the Indo-Pacific technique, there lacks any built-in deterrence measures and maritime safety aims within the Bay of Bengal.16
For a lot of littoral states of the Bay of Bengal, China is the main provider of navy {hardware}.17 A key instance is Bangladesh’s latest operationalization of the nation’s solely submarine base, BNS Sheikh Hasina, constructed with Chinese language monetary and technical help. Bangladesh additionally acquired China’s trendy VT5 gentle tank. Thailand has signed offers with China to accumulate floor warships and submarines for its navies.18 Myanmar’s airstrip extensions and building of aviation hangers on the Nice Coco Island suggests Chinese language involvement and potential makes use of for maritime surveillance.19 Moreover, China’s involvement in creating infrastructure in these international locations factors to a method of facilitating a long-term presence within the Bay of Bengal, in addition to laying steppingstones for blue water actions within the broader Indian Ocean.20
Chinese language Survey Vessels within the Grey Zone Marketing campaign: Pruning Hooks into Spears
There are three broad classes of Chinese language grey zone operations within the Bay of Bengal. These embrace its growth of maritime infrastructure, oceanographic survey vessel exercise, and undersea operations. Specifically, the frequent exercise of Chinese language oceanographic survey vessels over the previous few years are a key indicator that China is searching for a greater understanding of the undersea surroundings within the Bay of Bengal. These actions pave the way in which for submarine operations, which encourage a complete understanding of water currents, seabed topography, and seasonal variation of the maritime surroundings.21,22 This knowledge on undersea situations can also be helpful for understanding how submarine stealth will fare within the space.23 With respect to grey zone campaigns, submarine and subsurface belongings present a number of benefits, together with creeping coercion and operational uncertainty for focused states.24
A number of Chinese language oceanographic vessels have been on the forefront of this effort. The Shi Yan 1 was used within the Indian unique financial zone adjoining to the Andaman Nicobar Islands.25 The Xiang Yang Hong 06 carried out joint scientific surveys within the territorial sea of Myanmar in February 2020.26 This identical oceanographic survey vessel, previous to the Myanmar go to, carried out analysis on the seabed of Sri Lanka’s territorial sea.27 In choose offshore zones of Bangladesh, Chinese language survey ships carried out 2D seismic survey tasks.28
In pursuing grey zone actions within the Bay of Bengal, these Chinese language survey vessels repeat widespread operational patterns. First, these maritime analysis vessels, a few of which have ballistic missile and satellite tv for pc monitoring functionality, search clearance for replenishment functions, to be carried out at littoral state infrastructure.29 These survey vessels additionally usually swap off their computerized identification system (AIS) transponders, which makes it tough to trace their places and actions.30 After coming underneath worldwide strain Sri Lanka sought to delay a port go to by China’s Yuan Wang 5 ballistic missile and satellite tv for pc monitoring ship, however China utilized strain and was in a position to get the choice reversed. Sri Lanka allowed the ship to dock with sure stipulations, together with having the ship preserve its AIS transponder on.31, 32, 33
It’s value drawing specific consideration to the Indian Navy’s efforts at maritime area consciousness within the Bay of Bengal, since it’s complementary to the U.S. Navy’s targets and the built-in marketing campaign method required for U.S. Indo-Pacific technique. The Indian Navy’s Info Fusion Middle for the Indian Ocean Area exchanges data and facilitates communication with choose companions.34 The littoral states of Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and Myanmar are among the many companions on this safety collaboration construction.35 The Indian Navy’s deployment of coastal surveillance radar techniques in Bangladesh,36 Sri Lanka, and Myanmar highlights not solely its proactive efforts37 in addressing grey zone conditions,38 but in addition its concern in regards to the rising competitiveness of Chinese language grey zone operations. A salient function of the surveillance system is that the system can rapidly detect, find, and monitor actions of dhows and vessels in any given surveilled space.39
Due to these surveillance belongings specifically, the Indian Navy could be a helpful associate for the U.S. Navy in a Bay of Bengal built-in naval marketing campaign to counter China’s grey zone exercise.40 To compete with China’s grey zone operations, it’s critical for the U.S. Navy to kind regional partnership with the navies and coast guards of littoral states and enhance their capabilities.41 However the U.S. Navy principally focuses its operations within the neighborhood of East Asian littoral states, leaving a lot to be desired within the waters west of Malacca.42
China’s Undersea Technique within the Bay of Bengal
The frequent operations of Chinese language submarines and oceanographic survey vessels within the Bay of Bengal, the elevated detection and protests by the Indian Navy, and Sri Lanka’s replenishment of Chinese language vessels spotlight a fancy grey zone state of affairs within the Bay of Bengal. The state of affairs could also be much more complicated than beforehand thought as a result of hidden nature of Chinese language submarine operations within the space.
Previous to 2010, there was little proof of Chinese language submarine operations within the Bay of Bengal. Nevertheless, the state of affairs appeared to vary in 2014 when a Sort 039 Tune-class diesel-electric assault submarine berthed on the Sri Lankan port of Colombo twice: from September 7-14 and from October 31- November 6.43 The Tune class is way quieter than its predecessors attributable to its seven-bladed propeller, and the fight and command techniques of the submarine are upgraded variations of the techniques aboard the Sort 035 Ming-class submarine.44
Contemplating the similarity between Sort 039 and Sort 035 lessons, it’s noteworthy that China bought two Sort 035 G Ming-class submarines to Bangladesh45 in 2016, and a B-variant Ming-class submarine to Myanmar46 in 2021. China’s submarine offers with Bangladesh and Myanmar have paved the way in which for Chinese language submarine crews to be posted to those nations for coaching functions.47 These offers permit the Chinese language Navy to step by step enhance the presence of its personnel and Chinese language-sourced {hardware} within the Bay of Bengal’s littoral states, which enhance the competitiveness of its grey zone technique.
These developments ought to be a supply of concern for the U.S. Navy’s built-in naval marketing campaign in opposition to grey zone operations. China’s undersea operations problem the maritime area consciousness structure masking the Bay of Bengal, and the littoral states have comparatively little in the way in which of anti-submarine warfare capabilities. Chinese language submarine presence is due to this fact acutely felt on this area, even when it can’t be exactly perceived. The U.S. Navy might present important experience in enhancing consciousness of the undersea area and conducting anti-submarine warfare operations.
How the U.S. Navy can Lead an Built-in Marketing campaign in opposition to Grey Zone Challenges
The current-day prime management of the U.S. Navy views this decade as a decisive one and requires that the Navy enhance itself as a self-assessing, self-correcting, and at all times studying group to ship warfighting benefit.48 The management of the U.S. Navy understands the significance of fixing skillsets and tradition in relation to the competitors.49 The usNavy, in lots of its warfighting skillsets and operations, focuses on competing within the low-end spectrum of operations.50 This displays an applicable calculation of danger relating to allocating focus towards extra probably challenges to be encountered within the working surroundings, when the competitors is staying under the edge of battle.51,52
The U.S. Navy must concentrate on efficient grey zone counters that emphasize immediate and exact responses. Nevertheless, the challenges to grey zone competitiveness are multifaceted and embrace the price of offering bodily naval presence, in addition to managing the competitors over regional narratives that incessantly accompany grey zone campaigns. Subsequently the usNavy can’t confront grey zone operations alone. It should combine with the associate navies of the littoral states of the Indo-Pacific area.53 These associate navies should additionally take the initiative themselves to grasp the U.S. Navy’s views and capacities to affect the grey zone competitors within the Bay of Bengal, and develop choices for working collectively by means of an built-in marketing campaign.
Within the post-Chilly Struggle a long time, the U.S. Navy partnered with the littoral states of the Bay of Bengal for the needs of selling shared pursuits and fascinating in naval capability constructing, together with by means of bilateral and multilateral workouts. By means of the Joint Mixed Train Coaching (JCET), the Cooperation Afloat Readiness and Coaching (CARAT) and the Malabar Train, the U.S. Navy has helped regional navies help maritime safety and maritime area consciousness within the Bay of Bengal. Given this historical past of cooperation, the U.S. Navy is poised to take the lead on formulating an built-in naval marketing campaign for the Bay of Bengal. The substance of those workouts and their focus areas could be adjusted to raised match the grey zone challenges these associate nations are going through from China.
The Joint Mixed Train Coaching (JCET) occasion is a four-week lengthy train the place U.S. Naval Particular Warfare and the U.S. Particular Forces models prepare regional littoral navies to reinforce their fight readiness and maritime disaster response techniques.54 The CARAT occasion is a military-to-military bilateral train designed to focus on the flexibility of each the U.S. Navy and the regional littoral navy (e.g., Bangladesh) to reiterate shared ideas on maritime safety, stability, and prosperity. The collaborative initiative of CARAT is carried out at two phases: ashore and at sea.55 The ocean section of the CARAT consists of a minimum of three workouts appropriate to grey zone conditions.56 First, the cooperative potential to trace and pursue targets collectively by means of the coordinated deployment of floor ships and maritime patrol plane (i.e., navigation and tactical maneuvers). Second, bridge simulations designed to apply navigation maneuvering inside proximity to different vessels.57 Third, screening proficiency workouts to defend ships from potential threats.
The Malabar train is an Indo-Pacific navy interoperability train which encompasses two phases.58 The primary section consists of air protection, anti-submarine warfare, and replenishment-at-sea between ships, whereas the second section of Malabar includes cellular anti-submarine coaching goal train, cross-deck helicopter operations, and floor gunnery workouts.59 Every of those skillsets are related to grey zone operations, significantly kinetic exchanges on the low-end spectrum of warfare, and monitoring undersea exercise. In 2021, the U.S. Navy hosted the second section of Malabar within the Bay of Bengal. Additionally it is related to say that the Malabar train was first carried out in 1992 as a bilateral train between the U.S. Navy and the Indian Navy, with greater than 27 iterations since then.60 Because the train sequence continues, it will possibly constantly replace its content material to make sure it enhances capabilities which can be most related to the character of the regional competitors.
Conclusion
The presence of the U.S. Navy is waning compared to a Chinese language navy, coast guard, and maritime militia that’s quickly rising and turning into extra aggressive.61 Subsequently an efficient built-in naval marketing campaign shouldn’t be one thing that may be carried out solely by the U.S. Navy or a associate fleet. Fairly, built-in campaigning calls for the lively participation of all Indo-Pacific stakeholders which can be excited by enhancing rules-based order within the maritime area.
The strategic visions of the usNavy envision higher cooperation with worldwide associate navies.62 The U.S. Navy ought to establish easy methods to enhance collaboration to bolster deterrence and successfully compete under the edge of battle. It’s crucial to formulate a shared framework for early prognosis and immediate response to any potential grey zone actions.63 Operational cooperation between the usNavy and the regional navies of the Bay of Bengal could be a common matter of dialogue to type out shared maritime safety challenges, and develop an built-in marketing campaign that may competitively advance rules-based order.64
Mohammad Rubaiyat Rahman is a Instructing Assistant on the College of Texas at El Paso. He’s an issue skilled in maritime safety, irregular migration, counterinsurgency (COIN), and border disputes with a focus within the Indo-Pacific area. He contributed as a reviewer on the Journal of Indo-Pacific Affairs, an expert journal of the U.S. Division of Air Drive, and Coastal Administration (Taylor & Francis, 2022). He has revealed within the Journal of the Indian Ocean Area, Journal of Territorial & Maritime Research, and the Diplomat. He has introduced papers on the Asian Society of Worldwide Regulation, Nationwide College of Singapore, Jawaharlal Nehru College, and Bangladesh College of Engineering and Know-how.
References
[1] Jeffrey E. Kline. ‘Revamping Fleet Design and Maritime Technique: An Built-in Naval Marketing campaign for Benefit.’ CIMSEC. September 18, 2023. URL: https://cimsec.org/revamping-fleet-design-and-maritime-strategy-an-integrated-naval-campaign-for-advantage/ (accessed on October 25, 2023).
[2] Ibid.
[3] Simon Reich and Peter Dombrowski. ‘The Finish of Grand Technique: US Maritime Operations within the 21st Century’ (NY: Cornell College Press, 2017).
[4] C. Raja Mohan. Samudra Manthan: Sino-Indian Rivalry within the Indo-Pacific. (Washington: Carnegie Endowment for Worldwide Peace, 2012).
[5] Yatsuzuka Masaaki and Yamaguchi Shinji. ‘China’s Maritime Grey Zone Conditions’. Chapter 3. Eds. Yamaguchi Shinji, Yatsuzuka Masaki and Momma Rira, NIDS China Safety Report 2023: China’s Quest for Management of the Cognitive Area and Grey Zone Conditions. (Tokyo: Nationwide Institute of Protection Research, 2022)
[6] James Goldrick. ‘Gray zone operations and the maritime area’. The Strategist. October 30, 2018. URL: https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/grey-zone-operations-and-the-maritime-domain/ (accessed on October 26, 2023).
[7] Masaaki and Shinji, ‘China’s Maritime Grey Zone Conditions’, p. 54.
[8] Ibid, p. 55.
[9] Ibid.
[10] C. Raja Mohan. Samudra Manthan: Sino-Indian Rivalry within the Indo-Pacific. (Washington: Carnegie Endowment for Worldwide Peace, 2012).
[11] Mohammad Rubaiyat Rahman. ‘Appraising Built-in Deterrence Challenges in Bangladesh’s Indo-Pacific Outlook’. The Geopolitics. Could 17, 2023. URL: Appraising Built-in Deterrence Challenges in Bangladesh’s Indo-Pacific Outlook – The Geopolitics (accessed on October 28, 2023).
[12] Hal Manufacturers and Michael Beckley. ‘What does China need? Beijing’s ambitions are about to crash into its issues’. International Coverage. August 13, 2022. URL: China’s International Targets Are Stoppable (foreignpolicy.com) (accessed on October 28, 2023)
[13] ‘China’s Strategy to International Governance’. Council on International Relations. URL: China’s Strategy to International Governance | Council on International Relations (cfr.org) (accessed on October 23, 2023).
[14] C. Raja Mohan. Samudra Manthan: Sino-Indian Rivalry within the Indo-Pacific. (Washington: Carnegie Endowment for Worldwide Peace, 2012).
[15] E. John Teichert. ‘The US and China: Deterrence within the Hazard Zone’. The Diplomat. January 14, 2023. URL: The US and China: Deterrence within the Hazard Zone – The Diplomat (accessed on October 28, 2023)
[16] Rahman, ‘Appraising Built-in Deterrence Problem in Bangladesh’s Indo-Pacific Outlook.’
[17] Mohammad Rubaiyat Rahman. ‘Kilo impression within the Bay of Bengal’. The Diplomat. September 17, 2019. URL: https://thediplomat.com/2019/09/kilo-impact-in-the-bay-of-bengal/ (accessed on September 28, 2023).
[18] Manish Jung Pulami. ‘China’s rising forays into the Bay of Bengal’. November 30, 2020. URL: China’s Growing Forays into the Bay of Bengal – South Asian Voices (accessed on October 23, 2023)
[19] Sribala Subramanian. ‘An Airstrip on Myanmar’s Nice Coco Island’. The Diplomat. Could 04, 2023. URL: An Airstrip on Myanmar’s Nice Coco Island – The Diplomat (accessed on October 25, 2023).
[20] Saji Abraham. China’s Position in Indian Ocean: Its Implication on India’s Nationwide Safety. (New Delhi: Vij Books India, 2015).
[21] Geoffrey Until. Seapower: A Information for the Twenty-First Century. (New York: Routledge 2009), pp. 94-95.
[22] Xinhao Zhao, Yuchao Yuan and Wonyong Tang. ‘A sensible optimization methodology of submarine base contemplating vibration discount, lightweight, and shock resistance’. Ships and Offshore Constructions. Vol. 17, Problem: 11, pp. 2416-2427.
[23] Ibid.
[24] Iskander Rehman. ‘The Subsurface dimension of Sino-Indian Maritime Rivalry’. In India and China at Sea: Competitors for Naval Dominance within the Indian Ocean. Ed. David Brewster (New Delhi: Oxford College Press 2018) pp. 137-162, at 137.
[25] Ankit Panda. ‘Report: Indian Navy ejected Chinese language analysis ship from Indian Unique Financial Zone’. The Diplomat. December 09, 209. URL: https://thediplomat.com/2019/12/report-indian-navy-ejected-chinese-research-ship-from-indian-exclusive-economic-zone/ (Accessed on November 6, 2023).
[26] Zhu Feng and Cheng Hanping. ‘Myanmar’s help amid epidemic solidifies its deep Chinese language ties’ International Instances, February 16, 2020. URL: https://www.globaltimes.cn/content material/1179733.shtml (Accessed on November 3, 2023).
[27] Information.LK. ‘Chinese language analysis vessel ‘Xiang Yang Hong 06’ arrives on the port of Colombo’. January 18, 2020. URL: https://www.information.lk/information/political-current-affairs/merchandise/29205-chinese-research-vessel-xiang-yang-hong-06-arrives-at-the-port-of-colombo (Accessed on November 6, 2023).
[28] The Dhaka Tribune. ‘India Sad over survey by Chinese language ship within the Bay of Bengal’. February 09, 2023. URL: https://www.dhakatribune.com/world/asia/304584/india-unhappy-over-survey-by-chinese-ship-in-bay (Accessed on November 2, 2023).
[29] Rajeswari Pillai Rajagopalan, ‘India-China Tango Continues in Sri Lanka.’ The ORF Growth, October 10, 2023. URL: https://www.orfonline.org/analysis/india-china-tango-continues-in-sri-lanka/ (accessed on October 26, 2023).
[30] Hoang Do. ‘The right way to assist ASEAN deal with South China Sea ‘Grey-Zone’ challenges’. United States Institute of Peace. September 25, 2023. URL: https://www.usip.org/publications/2023/09/how-help-asean-address-south-china-sea-gray-zone-challenges (accessed on October 27, 2023).
[31] Hoang Do. ‘The right way to assist ASEAN deal with South China Sea ‘Grey-Zone’ challenges’. United States Institute of Peace. September 25, 2023. URL: https://www.usip.org/publications/2023/09/how-help-asean-address-south-china-sea-gray-zone-challenges (accessed on October 27, 2023).
[32] Nick Danby. ‘China’s ‘spy ship’ vist to Sri Lanka symbolises looming Sino-Indian maritime competitors’. The Strategist. September 28, 2022. URL: https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/chinas-spy-ship-visit-to-sri-lanka-symbolises-looming-sino-indian-maritime-competition/ (accessed on October 26, 2023).
[33] Masaaki Yatsuzuka. ‘How China’s maritime militia takes benefit of the gray zone’. The Strategist. January 16, 2023. URL: https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/how-chinas-maritime-militia-takes-advantage-of-the-grey-zone/ (accessed on October 25, 2023).
[34] Christian Wagner. ‘Looking out widespread safety within the Bay of Bengal’. Australian Journal of Maritime and Ocean Affairs. October 17, 2023. URL: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/18366503.2023.2270313 (Accessed on November 2, 2023).
[35] Indian Navy. Info Fusion Centre- Indian Ocean Area Annual Report 2022. URL: https://www.indiannavy.nic.in/ifc-ior/static/knowledge/studies/annual/3.%20IFC-IORpercent20Annualpercent20Reportpercent202022.pdf (Accessed on November 3, 2023).
[36] Anirban Bhaumik, ‘India’s radars in Bangladesh to observe Bay of Bengal’ The Deccan Herald. October 5, 2019. URL: https://www.deccanherald.com/india/indias-radars-in-bangladesh-to-monitor-bay-of-bengal-766567.html (Accessed on November 1, 2023).
[37] Indian Navy. Initiatives to Strengthen Coastal Safety. Press Launch. URL: https://www.indiannavy.nic.in/content material/initiatives-strengthen-coastal-security (Accessed on November 6, 2023)
[38] Ankit Panda. ‘India Unveils new Coastal Surveillance Radar Community’. The Diplomat. March 26. 2015. URL: https://thediplomat.com/2015/03/india-unveils-new-coastal-surveillance-radar-network/ (Accessed on October 30, 2023).
[39] Defence Analysis and Growth Group. Built-in Coastal Surveillance System (ICSS), URL: https://www.drdo.gov.in/integrated-coastal-surveillance-system-icss (Accessed on November 3, 2023).
[40] Lawrence Freedman. Command: The Politics of Navy Operations from Korea to Ukraine. (New York: Oxford College Press 2022).
[41] Cameron Smith. 2022. ‘Countering China’s Gray-Zone Diplomacy’. Australian Institute of Worldwide Affairs. 08 February 2022. Out there at URL: https://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/australianoutlook/countering-chinas-grey-zone-diplomacy/ (accessed on 25 October 2023).
[42] Abhijit Singh. ‘The U.S. Navy within the Indian Ocean: India’s ‘Gridlocks’ Dilemma’. Struggle on the Rocks. Could 11, 2021. URL: The U.S. Navy within the Indian Ocean: India’s ‘Goldilocks’ Dilemma – Struggle on the Rocks (accessed on 27 October, 2023).
[43] Sam LaGrone. ‘Chinese language Submarine Headed to Gulf of Aden for Counter Piracy Operations’. USNI Information. September 30, 2014. URL: https://information.usni.org/2014/09/30/chinese-submarine-headed-gulf-aden-counter-piracy-operations (Accessed on November 3, 2023).
[44] Navy At the moment. Tune Class: Patrol Submarine. URL: https://www.militarytoday.com/navy/song_class.htm (Accessed on November 1, 2023).
[45] Rahman, ‘Kilo Affect within the Bay of Bengal’.
[46] Xavier Vavasseur. ‘Myanmar Commissions Sort 035 B Ming-Class Submarine from China’. Naval Information. December 27, 2021. URL: https://www.navalnews.com/naval-news/2021/12/myanmar-commissions-type-35b-ming-class-submarine-from-china/ (Accessed on November 2, 2023).
[47] Captain Ariful Haque. ‘Subsequent-Technology ISR Dominance: Speed up Change or Lose Bangladesh’ Wild Blue Yonder. October 27, 2022. URL: https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Wild-Blue-Yonder/Article-Show/Article/3198619/next-generation-isr-dominance-accelerate-change-or-lose-bangladesh/#_edn16 (Accessed on November 6, 2023).
[48] Admiral Lisa Franchetti, ‘Message to the fleet’, August 23, 2023, url: https://s3.documentcloud.org/paperwork/23917551/nav23188.pdf (accessed on October 25, 2023).
[49] Ibid.
[50] Dmitry Filipoff, ‘A fleet adrift: The mounting risking of the U.S. Navy’s Drive Growth’. CIMSEC, February 13, 2023. URL: https://cimsec.org/a-fleet-adrift-the-mounting-risks-of-the-u-s-navys-force-development/ (accessed on October 22, 2023).
[51] Dmitry Filipoff, ‘Organizing for coaching and experimentation’ in Studying to Win: Utilizing operational innovation to regain the benefit at sea in opposition to China (Washington: Hudson Institute, 2022), p. 21.
[52] Ibid, p. 32.
[53] Lt Commanders Andrew Kramer and Martin Schroeder, U.S. Navy. 2020. “The Navy Wants a Grey-Zone Technique”. The U.S. Naval Institute, Vol. 146/6/1, 408; accessible at url: https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/2020/june/navy-needs-gray-zone-strategy (accessed on 25 October 2023).
[54] U.S. Embassy in Bangladesh. ‘U.S. Navy Concludes coaching with Bangladesh Navy’. Information & Occasions. November 10, 2022. URL: https://bd.usembassy.gov/28790/ (Accessed on: November 5, 2023).
[55] U.S. Embassy in Bangladesh. ‘U.S.-Bangladesh Navy Start CARAT Train’. Information & Occasion. November 5, 2018. URL: https://bd.usembassy.gov/u-s-bangladesh-navy-commence-Twenty fourth-carat-exercise/ (Accessed on November 6, 2023).
[56] Ibid.
[57] U.S. 7th Fleet Public Affairs. ‘U.S., Philippine Navies Conduct Bilateral Sail to Improve Interoperability’. Press Workplace: America’s Navy. Sept. 4, 2023. URL: https://www.navy.mil/Press-Workplace/Information-Tales/Article/3514805/us-philippine-navies-conduct-bilateral-sail-to-enhance-interoperability/ (Accessed on November 4, 2023).
[58] Ministry of Protection: Australian Authorities. ‘Australia to host train Malabar for the primary time’. Media Launch. August 11, 2023. URL: https://www.minister.defence.gov.au/media-releases/2023-08-11/australia-host-exercise-malabar-first-time (Accessed on November 1, 2023).
[59] Provider Strike Group 1 Public Affairs. ‘Australia, India, Japan, and U.S. Kick-off Section II: MALABAR 2021’. Press Workplace: America’s Navy. October 13, 2021. URL: https://www.navy.mil/Press-Workplace/Information-Tales/Article/2808152/australia-india-japan-and-us-kick-off-phase-ii-malabar-2021/ (Accessed on November 6, 2023).
[60] Jennifer Parker. ‘Not simply one other naval train: Malabar’s important messaging’ The Strategist. August 10, 2023. URL: https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/not-just-another-naval-exercise-malabars-vital-messaging/ (Accessed on November 2, 2023).
[61] Blake Herzinger. ‘The Navy ought to take extra teachers to sea’. American Enterprise Institute. January 6, 2023. URL: https://www.aei.org/op-eds/the-navy-should-take-more-academics-to-sea/ (accessed on October 25, 2023).
[62] Kevin Delamer, ‘Evaluation: The U.S. Navy’s Excessive-Low Combine’. USNI Information, June 10, 2013. URL: https://information.usni.org/2013/06/10/analysis-the-u-s-navys-high-low-mix (accessed October 21, 2023).
[63] Anastasia Kapetas. ‘Challenges for the US and Australia within the gray zone’. The Strategist. Could 6, 2021. URL: https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/challenges-for-australia-and-us-in-the-grey-zone/ (accessed on October 27, 2023)
[64] Karambir Singh and Blake Herzinger. ‘Partnership, not threats: The right way to Deepen U.S.-Indian Naval Cooperation’. Struggle on the Rocks. January 12, 2023. URL: https://warontherocks.com/2023/01/partnership-not-threats-how-to-deepen-u-s-indian-naval-cooperation/ (accessed on October 22, 2023).
Featured Picture: A submarine hooked up to a submarine flotilla with the navy underneath the PLA Northern Theater Command steams within the sea throughout a maritime drill on torpedo assault and protection, submarine management, and so on. on October 25, 2022. (eng.chinamil.com.cn/Photograph by Shi Jialong)
