The Duck Curve & Options For It

Join each day information updates from CleanTechnica on electronic mail. Or comply with us on Google Information!

Within the US, the “duck curve” is a California phenomena.

It’s a change to the legacy method of working era on the grid. The final time there was a signifiant change, and all of this was predicted lengthy earlier than it occurred, there was an excessive amount of photo voltaic in the course of the center of the day, however electrical charges nonetheless had a premium for noon consumption. This was out of step for utilities and system operators who had been coping with curtailment on the provision facet and lack of demand on the consumption facet.

So, slowly, after years, the California Public Utilities Fee (CPUC) modified its insurance policies and granted the utilities adjustments to get rid of daytime electrical charge premiums.

Now, the difficulty is completely different. The long-awaited duck curve situation is right here in an enormous method, with some days in spring now being 100% photo voltaic.

As proven, the issue with that is that photo voltaic era tapers off quickly on the finish of the day, and it’s tough to ramp era shortly in response for night consumption.

The CPUC beforehand raised charges within the early night hours as compensation. Power customers and utilities had been additionally enlisted to compensate for the wanted ramp in era. 

There are a number of easy options. The PUC and leaders in power found out that demand response or demand administration, native aggregated era, native aggregated demand response, storage, and different strategies equivalent to EIM, power imbalance markets, and a greater coordination of provide and demand between bigger areas might work on each the provision and consumption facet to ease the issue. Proper now, the quantities of utility storage are small. Usually, up to now, quick era responses had been made by easy fuel generators, which have low cost preliminary price, are quick beginning and ramping, have some operating prices and a few gasoline prices, and for probably the most half are perfect for sudden masses. Their general marginal price was normally larger than different era, however nothing else would try this job so cheaply and so effectively … till batteries got here alongside. Now battery power storage is cheaper than pure fuel vegetation and BESS are changing fuel generators progressively in California. This began way back to 2018 and has unfold to different elements of the US as battery power storage costs have plummeted.

However … the quantity of legacy quick era wanted in California previous to the duck curve was much less. The each day load curve was smoother and era ramping was slower, so fuel turbines and quick ramping era was confined largely to sudden system outage wants and comparatively rare occurrences like storms. Now extra quick response is required and that quick ramping era is required extra continuously, on nearly a each day foundation by means of massive elements of the 12 months, if not most of it.

There are answers working now, as a result of fuel generators usually are not the one era that may ramp. However when all or practically the entire era is photo voltaic throughout a day, and the remaining turbines should all ramp pretty shortly abruptly, it locations a pressure on operations. Up to now, this has been accommodated with none main incidences.

Nevertheless, the widespread consider all that is that, traditionally, the general public utility fee used an anachronistic mechanism designed to set charges on at most an annual foundation. That form of response is much too gradual to reply to fast seasonal, regional, and different occasions that occur rather more shortly in at this time’s fast-paced grid. As a substitute, foreknowledge ought to result in variations designed to hurry the response to extra fast adjustments. 

Right here, there’s a aim to attach market mechanisms, retail charges, to wholesale, and to attach utility and different era suppliers and buyer demand to provide in a extra coordinated solution to decrease prices and make the system work higher.

The CPUC didn’t situation a change to daytime electrical charge premiums till effectively after photo voltaic produced an oversupply of daytime electrical energy. That was too gradual. It did foresee the duck curve and moved to create treatments upfront, with some success.

One other entity within the chain of electrical power is the Impartial System Operator, or ISO, charged with working the system. It plans and adjusts era in accordance with demand patterns and demand prediction. It allocates and dispatches energy from utilities based on anticipated day-ahead or hour-ahead adjustments and works to steadiness era to demand.

In California, there are a number of ISOs. Some of the vital is CAISO.

What is occurring at this time

In some methods, the system has labored. Let’s give some examples.

First, the system didn’t collapse in response to 100% photo voltaic days this 12 months.

Second, a few of its responses, power storage, early night charge premiums, aggregated demand administration, and different issues labored to scale back the difficulty.

Listed below are some examples of how.

Demand Response Suppliers: “A DRP/aggregator is a business entity that gives demand response packages and providers equivalent to helping retail clients take part within the wholesale power market (operated by California Impartial System Operator, aka CAISO) and with methods or know-how to scale back their electrical consumption throughout occasions of grid wants in change for compensation.” Demand response can work with customers to scale back demand at strategic occasions.

On the ISO facet, CAISO lists these strategies out there below the demand response, or DR, heading: “The ISO gives varied load participation fashions to suit completely different useful resource traits. Use the Participation Comparability — Proxy Demand, Distributed Power Useful resource Supplier, Storage, and Load Forecast Adjustment.”

Demand response packages haven’t all gone completely. Actually, the CPUC determined to sundown one, however that call has had combined critiques. The CPUC arrange a factor known as DRAM, Demand Response Aggregator Market, an public sale for demand response mechanisms, however now it’s ending it in response to utility requests. This transfer has combined critiques.

There are DR aggregators for every little thing from massive retail to residential. One in every of them is OhmConnect, a service I thought-about at one time. It’s a program of voluntary demand reductions with incentives operated by OhmConnect below the DR packages arrange by the CPUC. The CPUC arrange packages below IOUs (investor owned utilities) and third celebration suppliers. OhmConnect is a 3rd celebration supplier. Curiously, Tesla can be a supplier. Its simple to check that any entity already offering storage might act to even be a requirement response supplier below the auspices of the CPUC.

OhmConnect works by notifying contributors about the necessity to decrease demand throughout particular hours. That is performed by customary communication strategies like electronic mail and SMS 24 hours upfront. Individuals should have good plugs and gadgets. There’s a listing on their web site. When notified, contributors robotically energy down masses at requested hours. OhmConnect contributors are rewarded for his or her responses.

Whereas this resolution and different DR and DRP options work, I’m a bit dissatisfied {that a} extra trendy, automated system is just not but used for DR. I envisioned a system the place good gadgets had been below voluntary management through direct means through the web. The system would permit customers to regulate how a lot and in the event that they selected to take part through an app that they management. That method, alerts may very well be broadcast quickly, responses can be automated and never require guide intervention or nags through snail mail and textual content, and usually would require much less user-required interplay. 

It might make it simple to take part. Most individuals are actually acquainted with utilizing apps like Nest or smarter home equipment. First customers are prone to get pleasure from utilizing the comfort, foregoing fixed participation by means of electronic mail nags in favor of extra handy person pleasant apps as an alternative, mixed with the simple choice of overriding participation on a case and use foundation — say, for an unscheduled have to function an equipment.

If billing incentives are operated on a utilization participation foundation, the person has the continual selection of which home equipment and the way a lot to function them in response to cost alerts from the era market.

I’ve all the time felt {that a} harmonization of the wholesale and retail markets, or provide and demand facet of the power markets, was so as, and would work to offer stability and advantages on all sides of the system. 

It seems to me that such a system would allow that.

An SMS and electronic mail notification is slower in comparison with a direct interconnect hyperlink. Good gadgets are already on WiFi. Why not make the hyperlink app hook up with the equipment immediately as an alternative of requiring each day guide person intervention creating one more chore for individuals, as an alternative of including comfort. To me, the largest situation right here is that, as a lot as doable, the interface between demand and provide should be managed by mechanisms with fast response quicker than 24 hours forward — I imply, quick, as in minutes at most. There isn’t any cause this can’t be achieved through mechanisms as I outlined right here.