Join every day information updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or comply with us on Google Information!
In a latest video by Fox Information, the corporate finds mainly each EV-negative headline they may discover for the final a number of years, after which interviews an automotive journalist who owns two older EVs. The conclusion? EVs are a failure.
Right here’s the video (I’ll discuss it extra afterward):
On the subject of media honesty, there are two methods to get it unsuitable. The plain approach to be dishonest is to current data that is wrong. Folks make errors (I actually have), however you’ll be able to retract and apologize whenever you get issues unsuitable. However, if you bought one thing unsuitable and run with it, that’s often called mendacity.
The opposite, way more frequent approach to get issues unsuitable is to make use of framing. You possibly can inform readers or viewers the reality, and solely inform them truthful issues, however nonetheless be dishonest by not sharing the entire fact. By selecting what truths to concentrate on and selecting what truths to disregard, you’ll be able to nonetheless use truths to color a dishonest image.
When you take a look at the construction of the video, it’s clearly designed to take an uncommon EV scenario and encompass it with different out-of-context half-truths to normalize the irregular. It begins with a montage of unhealthy tales about EV charging and EVs. Charging reliability, the time it takes to construct stations, and manufacturing cuts are all sewn collectively to make a monster that Dr. Frankenstein would blush seeing.
Then, in the course of the sandwich, they current the very true story of The Autopian‘s David Tracy. He’s an auto fanatic who has two EVs in his assortment. One is a BMW i3 REx, an EV with a small bike engine that powers a variety extender. The opposite is a 2011 Nissan LEAF with a heavily-degraded battery, with solely 20 miles of vary remaining on flat floor. With no vary extender, these early LEAFs are nugatory apart from some very quick vary driving (I’ve owned the very same yr).
However is the common Fox viewer going to know that this previous LEAF is a extremely uncommon EV from mainly the start of the trendy EV period? No. As we’ve seen time and again, individuals who don’t know a lot about EVs will suppose that this car is the norm and never a distant exception. So, once they see that the LEAF acquired stranded as a result of an Electrify America station in California was down, this smears all EVs.
However, each sandwich should have one other slice of bread to maintain the meat and cheese or peanut butter and jelly inside and off your fingers. So, the video then goes to a different montage of unhealthy EV story clippings from latest occasions.
Fox wasn’t proud of this. They needed to make a Dagwood. After this piece of bread, they return to extra “meat.” David says that California’s EV charging infrastructure is best than the remainder of the nation. That is considerably true, however on the similar time, no person’s making infrastructure with a 20-mile EV in thoughts. Plus, Electrify America’s stations have had greater issues there due to increased utilization charges.
At this level, David really could be very trustworthy about EVs. He mentions that they’re quite a bit higher in case you have charging at residence. He mentions that they’re a bit of costlier than ICE automobiles. He mentions that they’re nice whenever you’re coping with fuel costs such as you see in California. However, behind the audio of him telling the reality, Fox places up a bunch of screenshots portray all the pieces he’s saying (professionals and cons each) as a part of one thing Biden is behind. Biden, Biden, Biden.
Once more, on the video’s finish, David is being completely trustworthy. He thinks that hybrids are an excellent interim answer whereas EV infrastructure improves and will get prepared for extra EVs. Many EV house owners would agree with this. However, most EV house owners wouldn’t agree with the framing of the story and the dearth of context.
The Context Fox Conveniently Left Out
Many EV followers who’ve purchased a brand new automotive within the final 3-4 years won’t know a lot about this, however the 2011 Nissan LEAF was actually from a really completely different period within the trendy EV age. As a substitute of attempting to supply a car that folks may use as a major and solely automotive, the purpose with the LEAF was to make a automotive individuals may afford in a time when battery cells have been extraordinarily costly. The end result was a automotive that price round $40,000 that might solely go round 80 miles.
On the time, there have been solely a small variety of fast chargers within the largest cities for the LEAF to make use of. So, individuals solely used them for commuting and had a second ICE car they’d use for long-distance driving. They’d cost the car up at residence, drive to work and again, and cost it once more.
Sadly, even this didn’t work out for the primary couple of years of LEAFs. The expertise was new, and Nissan didn’t know that in any local weather with a lot warmth that the batteries wouldn’t final for lengthy. Some individuals misplaced half of the automotive’s vary within the first few months of possession within the hottest locations like Phoenix. Someday between 2013 and 2015, Nissan created a brand new battery chemistry (often called the “lizard battery”) that might deal with the warmth higher. However even newer fashions with bigger battery packs continued to endure from untimely vary loss and gradual charging on journeys as a result of Nissan by no means included a cooling system within the LEAF!
A number of different producers made city-only automobiles (often called “compliance automobiles” through the mid 2010s. These automobiles additionally typically had lower than 100 miles of vary. The Chevy Spark EV, the Ford Focus EV, and Toyota’s second-gen Rav4 EV (powered by Tesla batteries and motors) all glad EV quotas in states like California with out actually offering individuals with an EV that may very well be your solely automotive.
Aside from the earliest of Tesla automobiles, that firm took a special strategy. The Mannequin S and the later Mannequin X had sufficient vary to be a standard automotive, however got here in at extraordinarily excessive costs. However, the corporate earned a status for higher automobiles whereas everybody else was wanting like fools. The corporate additionally instituted an aggressive buildout of EV charging infrastructure that allowed Tesla automobiles to turn into regular road-trippers years earlier than each different producer in the USA.
Now, nearly each EV offered has over 200 miles of vary, non-Tesla infrastructure is bettering, and practically each different producer has a take care of Tesla to make use of the corporate’s charging stations someday this yr.
In different phrases, the knowledge Fox gave us about EVs is a few decade old-fashioned and never the norm for anyone shopping for an EV in 2024.
Featured picture: A 2011 Nissan LEAF I used to personal. Picture by Jennifer Sensiba.
Have a tip for CleanTechnica? Need to promote? Need to recommend a visitor for our CleanTech Discuss podcast? Contact us right here.
Newest CleanTechnica.TV Video
CleanTechnica makes use of affiliate hyperlinks. See our coverage right here.
