Essay by Eric Worrall
If storms are getting worse, how can fragile renewable vitality infrastructure survive the superstorms of the long run?
After a bizarre summer time of floods and heatwaves, scientists clarify why climate extremes are ‘on steroids’
By local weather reporter Jess Davis
When winds as excessive as 260 kilometres per hour tore down transmission towers in South Australia in 2016 and plunged the state into an electrical energy void, it took folks abruptly.
The sight of high-voltage transmission strains, crumpled on the bottom was nearly surreal.
Eight years later, as fierce storms broke over Victoria, photos of wilted towers have been once more inflicting consternation.
…
Storms get extra intense
What local weather scientists do know is that with extra vitality within the ambiance, storms have gotten extra intense.
“When you will have occasions like squall strains or cyclones, tornadoes, thunderstorms, they’ve extra vitality out there to them,” director of the Monash Vitality Institute Roger Dargaville stated.
Dr Dargaville stated he was shocked wind may knock over transmission towers again in 2016, however that’s not the case.
“It’s now a really actual risk and can most likely happen many occasions sooner or later,” he stated.
…
Learn extra: https://www.abc.web.au/information/2024-02-28/global-warming-effect-on-extreme-weather-events/103471564
Professor Dargaville additionally just lately argued for extra renewables;
Monash professional: Wild climate aftermath – the safety of Victoria’s vitality grid and the necessity for renewables
Monash College
14/02/2024
Affiliate Professor Roger Dargaville, Director Monash Vitality Institute, Sources Engineering, College of EngineeringMonash College specialists can be found to touch upon the facility blackout and associated aftermath on account of wild climate in Victoria yesterday, and the way our vitality grids could possibly be made extra resilient sooner or later.
…
The next may be attributed to Affiliate Professor Dargaville:
“On Tuesday afternoon, a extreme storm belt with wind gusts over 100km/h, excessive lightning and torrential rain induced havoc throughout Melbourne. Amongst plenty of localised energy outages as a consequence of low voltage energy strains being broken was the destruction of a number of towers supporting the parallel 500kV strains between Melbourne and Geelong. The impact of shedding that important infrastructure was to ‘journey off’ the Loy Yang An influence station.
…
“Distributed renewable vitality techniques provide each extra vulnerability as a consequence of extra infrastructure unfold over wider areas, but additionally further resilience as losses of particular person energy strains don’t have the identical affect of shedding massive centralised energy stations.
…
Even when we assume for a second this tremendous storm declare is true, Professor Dargaville’s place doesn’t make sense.
Take into account these options propositions for future vitality era:
- Construct an vitality system which depends upon huge acreages of fragile sheets of glass and machines designed to catch the wind, together with vastly enlarged energy grids to seize this dispersed vitality, which will likely be massively weak to the raging superstorms of the long run.
- Construct a set of compact nuclear reactors encased in thick metal and concrete armour, positioned at a adequate elevation to remove the chance of flooding, totally invulnerable to any potential storm, positioned as shut as potential to vitality finish customers, to minimise the chance of provide disruption brought on by storm harm to distribution networks.
Why is Professor Dargaville advocating for the choice which he admits is will enhance vulnerability to storm harm, and never even mentioning the nuclear choice, which gives close to complete local weather resilience and a gentle provide of dependable and dispatchable zero carbon vitality?
Fragile, climate dependent renewable vitality techniques should not match for goal, and can by no means be match for goal. They don’t make sense immediately, and they might make even much less sense in a future crammed with local weather superstorms.
Don’t suppose for a second I take the declare of future superstorms critically, why ought to the present crop of alarmist local weather predictions be any completely different to the earlier 30 years+ of failed local weather predictions? However Professor Dargaville’s advocacy of renewable vitality doesn’t make sense, even within the context of his personal claimed place on future local weather disruption.
Associated
